Tool Tutorials

Ahrefs vs Semrush for Backlinks (2026): Which Is Better?

By BacklinkPrice Team · Nov 22, 2026 · 5 min read
Cover image for Ahrefs vs Semrush for Backlinks (2026): Which Is Better?

A side-by-side comparison of Ahrefs and Semrush for backlink research, audits and outreach, with index claims and prices.

For backlink work in 2026, Ahrefs is the better pick if link research is most of your job, thanks to its fast-updating index, Link Intersect and cheaper Lite plan. Semrush is the better pick if backlinks are one task among many, because it bundles a Backlink Audit, a Link Building Tool with outreach, and broader marketing features.

Both tools are strong, and both claim very large link indexes. The right choice depends on whether you need a link specialist or an all-in-one suite.

Key takeaways

  • Semrush states an index of over 43 trillion backlinks; Ahrefs lists about 35 trillion as historical records.
  • Index claims are measured differently, so raw totals aren't directly comparable.
  • Ahrefs Lite starts at $129 a month; Semrush Pro starts at $139.95.
  • Semrush includes Backlink Audit and an outreach-ready Link Building Tool.
  • Ahrefs leads on link-gap analysis with Link Intersect for up to 10 competitors.
FactorAhrefsSemrush
Stated backlink index~35T (historical records)43T+
Stated referring domains~285M~390M
Entry price (monthly)$129 (Lite)$139.95 (Pro)
Link gap toolLink Intersect (up to 10 competitors)Backlink Gap
Toxic link auditManual review, no toxicity scoreBacklink Audit with risk markers
Built-in outreachNoYes (Link Building Tool)
Authority metricDomain Rating (DR)Authority Score (AS)

Prices and index claims change often. Check each vendor before buying.

How we compared them

Based on vendor documentation, published index claims and independent reviews.

We compared the backlink features each tool documents, the index sizes reported by independent comparisons, and current entry prices. We didn't run our own index test. As Ahrefs itself argues in a post on comparing link counts, tools count links in different ways, so totals can mislead.

Our guide on which backlink tool has the biggest index covers the index debate in more depth.

Index size and freshness

Semrush claims more links; Ahrefs focuses on freshness.

A Rework comparison reports Semrush's claim of more than 43 trillion backlinks across 390 million referring domains. It lists Ahrefs at 35 trillion external backlinks as historical records and 285 million referring domains.

Experte's comparison notes Ahrefs says its index updates every 15 to 30 minutes, so deleted links drop out faster. For active campaigns, fresher data can matter more than total size.

Ahrefs has the edge for competitor gap analysis.

Ahrefs' Link Intersect shows domains linking to competitors but not to you, with up to 10 competitors and filters for page-level or domain-level views. Semrush's Backlink Gap does a similar job and can push prospects straight into its Link Building Tool.

If you run gap analysis every week, Ahrefs' filters are usually faster to work with. Our guide on how to do a backlink gap analysis shows the process in either tool.

Semrush is stronger for structured audits.

Semrush's Backlink Audit groups links by risk markers and lets you build a disavow file in the tool. Ahrefs shows referring domains, anchors and link types, but leaves the judgement to you.

Neither score reflects Google's own view. Our guide on how to do a backlink audit explains when an audit is worth the time.

Semrush covers outreach; Ahrefs doesn't.

Semrush's Link Building Tool finds prospects from your keywords and competitors, then lets you email them and track replies after connecting your inbox. Ahrefs has no outreach module, so you'll need a separate tool such as BuzzStream or Pitchbox.

Authority metrics

DR and AS measure different things.

Ahrefs' Domain Rating is based mainly on a site's link profile. Semrush's Authority Score blends link data with traffic and spam signals. Neither is a Google metric. Our comparison of Ahrefs DR vs Moz DA vs Semrush AS explains the differences.

Ahrefs is cheaper to start; Semrush includes more.

Ahrefs Lite costs $129 a month, with Standard at $249. Semrush Pro costs $139.95, with Guru at $249.95. Ahrefs also has a $29 Starter plan, but it is limited for link research.

Compare what you'll actually use. If you'd buy a separate audit or outreach tool alongside Ahrefs, Semrush may cost less overall.

How to run a fair side-by-side trial

Test both tools on the same sites in the same week.

Pick your own site and three competitors. In each tool, record referring domains, the top 20 linking domains and the newest links found in the last 30 days. Then check which tool found links you already know exist.

Next, run one gap analysis and one prospect list in each. Time how long each takes and how many prospects survive your manual quality check. Our guide on how to analyze competitor backlinks gives a checklist you can reuse.

Common mistakes when comparing them

Don't judge either tool on total link counts alone.

The biggest mistake is comparing headline numbers. One tool may count every sitewide footer link, while the other groups them. Referring domains, link freshness and filter quality matter more for daily work.

Another mistake is assuming a missing link means a weak index. New links often take days to appear. Our explainer on why backlinks don't show in Ahrefs covers the usual reasons, and most apply to Semrush too.

Finally, avoid buying an annual plan before testing your real workflow. Monthly billing costs more but lets you switch if the tool doesn't fit.

Which should you choose?

Pick by workflow, not by brand.

Choose Ahrefs if you're a link builder or agency doing heavy competitor research, link gap work and prospect discovery. Choose Semrush if you want audits, outreach and wider SEO and content features in one subscription.

Many teams use both: Ahrefs for research and Semrush for audits and reporting. If budget allows only one, try each on a trial and run the same three competitor checks in both.

Frequently Asked Questions

Ahrefs is usually preferred by dedicated link builders for its fresh index and Link Intersect. Semrush is better if you also want audits, outreach and broader marketing tools.

Semrush claims the larger total, over 43 trillion backlinks. Ahrefs says totals aren't comparable because tools count links differently.

Not in the same way as Semrush. Ahrefs gives the data for a manual audit but doesn't assign toxicity scores.

Yes. Its Link Building Tool lets you find prospects, send emails and track progress after connecting your email account.

Is there a free version of either tool?

Ahrefs Free covers verified sites. Semrush's free account allows 10 analytics requests a day.

Sources

BacklinkPrice Team
Written by
BacklinkPrice Team
Link building and backlink pricing research

The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.

More from BacklinkPrice Team

Related guides