How-To Guides

Are Social Bookmarking Links Worth It?

By BacklinkPrice Team · Nov 19, 2026 · Updated Nov 20, 2026 · 8 min read
Illustrated cover for Are Social Bookmarking Links Worth It?

Social bookmarking links are rarely worth chasing for rankings, but they can still pay off for traffic and discovery when you post by hand in active communities.

Social bookmarking links are rarely worth chasing for rankings, but they can still be worth using for traffic and discovery. Most carry nofollow or ugc marks, so Google treats them as hints rather than votes, so use them on a few active sites and do not buy bulk submissions.

Key takeaways

  • Google lists low-quality directory or bookmark site links as link spam in its spam policies, as of November 2026.
  • Google introduced nofollow in 2005, added sponsored and ugc on 10 September 2019, and made nofollow a hint for crawling on 1 March 2020.
  • Links marked nofollow, ugc, or sponsored will generally not be followed, according to Google Search Central.
  • Ahrefs studied 44,589 search results pages and found the link between dofollow backlinks and rankings was slightly weaker than the link for total backlinks.
  • A nofollow link can still send readers who later link to you, as Ahrefs shows with a Quora answer.

Social bookmarking links are links you save or share on a public bookmarking site so other people can find and discuss them. Social bookmarking covers sites where users post links with tags, titles, and short notes.

The classic sites were built for saving links, not for publishing full articles. Reddit, Pinterest, Hacker News, and Flipboard are the best-known sites still in wide use today.

A bookmarking link differs from an editorial link because you place it yourself. An editor did not choose it, review it, and add it to a page they control. That self-placed nature is why search engines treat it with care.

UseRanking valueMain payoffRisk
Bulk submission to many sitesVery lowAlmost noneLink spam
One post in an active communityLowVisits and mentionsLow if rules are followed
UseRanking valueMain payoffRisk
Sharing a useful guideLowReaders who may link laterLow
Posting only your own linksLowFew visitsRemoval or ban

Google says low-quality directory or bookmark site links are link spam. That line sits in the link spam section of its spam policies, as of November 2026. Google also lists automated programs that create links to your site as link spam in the same section.

Google says sites that break its spam policies may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all. It detects policy breaches with automated systems and, where needed, human review that can lead to a manual action. That is the risk side of bulk bookmarking.

Google launched its Penguin webspam update on 24 April 2012. Search Engine Land reported in 2012 that it would affect about 3.1% of English queries, 3% in German, Chinese and Arabic, and 5% in Polish.

In Moz's 2015 study, reported by Search Engine Journal in 2015, the 150 surveyed SEOs rated total unnatural links as the strongest negative ranking signal, ahead of thin or duplicate content.

Google also says links marked with nofollow, ugc, or sponsored will generally not be followed.

Most bookmarking links pass little ranking value because sites mark user-submitted links so Google does not count them as votes. Google recommends the ugc value for links in comments and forum posts, and it says marked links will generally not be followed. A nofollow link tells Google not to pass ranking credit in the usual way.

Google introduced nofollow in 2005 to fight comment spam. On 10 September 2019, it added sponsored and ugc, and it said all three values are treated as hints about which links to count or leave out. Nofollow became a hint for crawling and indexing on 1 March 2020.

Ahrefs notes that most links from social networks, forums, and directories are nofollowed, and WordPress adds nofollow to comment links by default. Check the difference between dofollow and nofollow links before you count a bookmarking link as a ranking asset.

Ahrefs studied 44,589 search results pages and found the link between dofollow backlinks and rankings was slightly weaker than the link for total backlinks. Ahrefs warned readers to take that finding with a large pinch of salt, since the study did not isolate the nofollow factor.

Bookmarking links are still worth it when the page sits in front of people who read, click, and share it. A link on Reddit or Pinterest can send visitors on the same day you post it. That traffic is the main payoff, not a ranking jump.

They are also worth it for discovery. A reader who finds your guide through a bookmark can link to it from their own site. Ahrefs gives one case where a nofollow link in a Quora answer led a reader to write an article with a followed link to Ahrefs.

Social signals and backlinks are not the same thing, and shares alone do not act as votes. Treat a bookmark as distribution, not as a backlink. If your topic has no active community on that site, the link is not worth your time.

How to use social bookmarking the right way

Use bookmarking as a small, manual habit, not as a mass submission task. Pick two or three sites where your readers already spend time. Links from Reddit work best when you take part in the community first.

  1. Read the rules of each site and community before you post your first link.
  1. Share only your best page on that topic, with a clear title that matches the content.
  1. Add a short, honest note that says what the reader will learn, in your own words.
  1. Answer replies and questions on the post for at least a day after you share it.
  1. Post a link to someone else's useful page for every link you post to your own site.

Do not use software to submit the same link to dozens of sites. Google lists automated link creation as link spam, and one good post in the right place beats 50 posts no one sees.

Google's guide to user-generated spam adds one more reason to keep it manual. It says spammers are often motivated by leaving a link, and it tells site owners to consider adding nofollow or ugc to all links in untrusted content.

Tools, time, and cost

You need no paid tool to start bookmarking, and do not pay for bulk submission packages. A free account on each site, plus Google Search Console to check clicks, is enough for most small sites.

Plan on 30 to 60 minutes a week for two sites. That covers picking one page, writing a short note, posting it, and replying to comments. The cost is your time, and the return is measured in visits.

To check link marks, use your browser's inspect tool. Right-click a link, choose Inspect, and look for rel="nofollow" or rel="ugc" in the HTML. Ahrefs also notes that its Site Explorer Overview report shows the share of followed and nofollowed referring domains for a site.

How to measure results

Measure bookmarking by visits and by what those visits lead to, not by the number of links you placed. Check referral traffic in your analytics tool for each site, by week, for at least four weeks after you post.

Watch for second-order effects too, such as new referring domains and new brand searches in the weeks after a post. A backlink audit can show whether a bookmark post led to a followed link from another site, as in the Ahrefs Quora case. That chain is the real test.

Set a simple rule before you start. If a site sends no referral visits after four honest posts, stop posting there. If a site sends visits but no new links or sign-ups, keep it as a traffic source only.

Common mistakes

  • Submitting to dozens of sites: bulk posts create the pattern Google calls link spam.
  • Posting only your own links: communities remove self-promotion fast.
  • Using keyword-stuffed titles: a title that misleads readers gets downvotes and removals, not clicks.
  • Counting nofollow links as ranking links: a marked link can send traffic, but it does not pass ranking credit.
  • Ignoring the rules: each community has its own rules on self-promotion, and a ban costs you the audience.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, not directly in most cases. Most bookmarking sites mark user links with nofollow or ugc, so Google treats them as hints rather than votes. They can still help by sending readers who later link to you. That indirect path is slow, so do not count on it for fast rankings.

They can be, if you place them in bulk to move rankings. Google lists low-quality directory or bookmark site links as link spam in its spam policies. A single honest post in a real community is not the same as automated mass submission.

Which bookmarking sites are best?

Pick the sites where your readers already spend time. Reddit suits discussion and niche topics, Pinterest suits visual topics such as food, home, and fashion, and Hacker News suits tech topics. Test two or three sites for four weeks, then keep the ones that send visits.

Build very few, and build them by hand. Two or three good posts a week on active sites beat 100 automated submissions. If a site sends no visits after four honest posts, stop posting there and use that time elsewhere.

Yes, if you use them in bulk or with automated tools. Google says sites that break its spam policies may rank lower or not appear in results at all. Keep the volume low, post by hand, and follow each community's rules to stay clear of that risk.

Sources

For a wider plan that puts bookmarking in its place, see how to create a link building strategy.

BacklinkPrice Team
Written by
BacklinkPrice Team
Link building and backlink pricing research

The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.

More from BacklinkPrice Team

Related guides