Link Building

Examples of Link Schemes Google Penalizes (With Real Cases)

By BacklinkPrice Team · Nov 22, 2026 · 5 min read
Illustrated cover for Examples of Link Schemes Google Penalizes (With Real Cases)

The link schemes Google's spam policies name, with real penalty cases from Interflora, J.C. Penney, Overstock and Rap Genius, and what each one teaches.

Google penalizes link schemes such as buying or selling links that pass ranking credit, paid advertorials with followed links, excessive link exchanges, large-scale guest posting with keyword-rich anchors, automated link building, and links hidden in widgets or site footers.

Real cases show the cost: Interflora, J.C. Penney, Overstock, and Rap Genius all lost Google visibility after link scheme penalties.

Key takeaways

  • Google's spam policies define link schemes as links intended to manipulate rankings, and list specific examples.
  • Interflora lost much of its Google visibility for 11 days in 2013 after paid advertorials on regional news sites.
  • J.C. Penney regained its rankings after a 90-day penalty in 2011 for paid links.
  • Overstock was penalized in 2011 for offering discounts in exchange for links from university sites.
  • Most link penalties are lifted once the links are removed or qualified and a reconsideration request is approved.
SchemeWhat it looks likeSafe alternative
Buying or selling linksPaying for followed linksMark paid links rel="sponsored"
Excessive link exchanges"Link to me and I'll link to you" at scaleNatural, relevant links only
Advertorials with followed linksPaid articles passing ranking creditDisclose and qualify the links
Large-scale guest posting with rich anchorsMany posts with exact-match anchorsFewer, relevant posts with natural anchors
Automated link buildingSoftware creating linksManual, editorial outreach
Required links in terms of serviceLinks forced without qualificationAllow nofollow or sponsored
Widget and footer linksKeyword links in embeds or templatesBranded, qualified links
Low-quality directories and bookmarksMass submissionsReal, curated local listings
Forum signature and comment linksOptimized anchors in postsHelpful participation without link spam

The key question is intent to manipulate rankings.

Google's spam policies say Google uses links as a factor in ranking, and that links intended to manipulate rankings may be treated as link spam. That covers links to your site and links out from it.

Read what is a link scheme for the full definition.

Example 1: Paid advertorials (Interflora, 2013)

Paid news articles with followed links triggered a fast penalty.

Search Engine Watch reported that UK florist Interflora placed about 150 advertorials on regional news sites. Its rankings returned after 11 days.

Search Engine Land noted that two days after the penalty, Google issued a warning against advertorials that pass PageRank.

Lesson: sponsored content is fine, but links in it must be qualified.

A large retailer was not protected by its size.

According to the same Search Engine Land report, J.C. Penney regained its Google visibility after a 90-day timeout in 2011.

Lesson: a big brand name does not offset a link-buying campaign.

Incentives count as payment.

Martech's list of big brands penalized by Google describes how Overstock ran into trouble for offering discounts in exchange for links, including from university sites.

Lesson: giving goods, services, or discounts for followed links is still a paid link. See are paid links against Google guidelines.

Asking bloggers to add keyword links in exchange for promotion is a scheme.

The Martech list notes that Rap Genius had its penalty lifted after 10 days in December 2013 once it worked to remove unnatural links.

Lesson: exchanging promotion for links counts. Read is a link exchange the same as a link scheme.

Sellers can be penalized too.

Search Engine Roundtable reported widespread penalties tied to advertorials in February 2013. Coverage at the time described reduced PageRank for some UK newspaper sites that sold the links.

Lesson: selling followed links can hurt the publisher's own standing.

Example 6: Sponsored blog posts (Google Chrome, 2012)

Google applied the rules to its own product.

Search Engine Land's Interflora report also recalls that the Google Chrome website was given a 60-day penalty after a paid blog post campaign that violated Google's guidelines.

Lesson: the rules apply no matter who runs the campaign, and agencies working for you can create the problem.

Most schemes are sold as shortcuts.

  • A guaranteed number of "DA 50+" links per month for a fixed fee.
  • Sites with no real audience but long lists of "write for us" categories.
  • Requests for exact-match anchors on every placement.
  • Offers to hide the payment or avoid rel="sponsored".
  • Packages that mix hundreds of directory, profile, and comment links.

If an offer shows several of these signs, walk away. Read signs of a Google link penalty to spot damage from past campaigns.

Other common schemes

These rarely make headlines but still get flagged.

  • Private blog networks: sites built only to link to a money site.
  • Widget links: keyword-rich links hidden in embeddable tools or themes.
  • Footer links: site-wide links across many client sites.
  • Comment and forum spam: optimized anchors in signatures and replies.
  • Directory blasts: hundreds of low-quality directory submissions.

What happens after a penalty

Manual actions appear in Search Console.

Google's Manual Actions report help page explains how to see and fix manual actions. Read what is a Google manual action for unnatural links.

Fixing usually means removing or qualifying the links, disavowing what you cannot remove, and filing a reconsideration request. See how to recover from a link penalty.

How to stay safe

  • Mark every paid, sponsored, or incentivized link rel="sponsored" or nofollow.
  • Keep guest posts few, relevant, and with natural anchors.
  • Avoid site-wide footer or widget links with keyword anchors.
  • Audit new backlinks monthly for spam patterns.
  • Keep records of sponsorships and partnerships.

Frequently Asked Questions

Buying or selling links that pass ranking credit, including paid guest posts and link insertions without rel="sponsored" or nofollow.

Yes, when exchanges are excessive or made only to pass ranking credit. Occasional natural links between related sites are normal.

It varies. Interflora's lasted 11 days and J.C. Penney's about 90 days, after the links were dealt with.

Not on their own. Large-scale guest posting campaigns with keyword-rich anchor links are named as a scheme in Google's spam policies.

Check the Manual Actions report in Search Console. Sharp, unexplained ranking drops can also be a sign of algorithmic devaluation.

Sources

BacklinkPrice Team
Written by
BacklinkPrice Team
Link building and backlink pricing research

The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.

More from BacklinkPrice Team

Related guides