How to Get Backlinks with Expert Roundups: Step-by-Step (2026)

An expert roundup earns backlinks when you ask several experts one sharp question, publish their answers, and tell each expert the post is live.
An expert roundup earns backlinks when you ask several experts one sharp question, publish their answers with links to their sites, and tell each expert the post is live. Most experts share a post that features them, and some link to it from their own sites. The method works best for a question your audience already asks.
Key takeaways
- Roundup emails earn above-average replies (Backlinko, 2019; 12 million emails).
- Ask one sharp question and invite 20 to 30 relevant experts.
- One follow-up adds 65.8% more replies, per Backlinko's 2019 study.
- Lists of 51 to 100 emails averaged 12.08 links (BuzzStream, 2025).
- Judge a roundup by new referring domains, not raw link counts.
What an expert roundup is
An expert roundup is a post that collects short answers from several experts on one question. Each expert answers the same question in their own words, and you publish the answers with a short bio and a link to each expert's site. Readers get many views in one place, and each expert has a reason to share the post.
A roundup is not a list of quotes pulled from other sites. You ask the question yourself, and the experts answer it for your post. That direct ask is what makes the post original, and it is also what gives experts a reason to link back. A roundup built from copied quotes gives no one a reason to share it.
The format is close to ego bait, but the two are not the same. Ego bait praises people to win their attention, while a roundup asks a real question and prints useful answers.
Pick experts for what they know, not only for the size of their audience. A small expert with a clear answer often helps readers more than a famous name with a vague reply.
Why expert roundups earn backlinks
Expert roundups earn backlinks because each person you feature has a reason to share the post and link to it. An expert who gave you a quote can point their own readers to it, and readers who find the post useful can link to it as a source of many views.
The links come from the feature itself, not from a payment or a swap.
It pairs well with original research, since both formats give other writers a reason to cite you.
The outreach data backs this up. Backlinko's 2019 study of 12 million outreach emails found that emails about roundups, guest posts, and link building had above-average reply rates. The study also found that only 8.5% of all outreach emails got any reply, so a roundup invite still needs a strong question and a tight list to stand out.
Referring domains matter more than raw link counts here. Ahrefs' 2025 study of the top 1,000,000 keywords in the United States found referring domains had a 0.255 Spearman correlation with rankings, ahead of total backlinks at 0.248 and Domain Rating at 0.131. Ten links from 10 new sites beat 10 links from one site.
How to get backlinks with expert roundups
You get backlinks from an expert roundup by running it as a short project with a deadline, not as an open-ended request. Pick one question, invite a tight list of experts, publish fast, and tell every expert the day the post goes live. The steps below take most people 2 to 4 weeks from first invite to published post.
Step 1: Pick one sharp question
Pick a question your audience already asks, and word it so an expert can answer it in 2 to 4 sentences. Good questions ask for a choice, a method, or a prediction, such as which tactic a beginner should try first. Vague questions such as "What is your best SEO tip?" produce vague answers that no one links to.
Check that the question has not been answered to death in your niche. Search for it and read the top results. If 5 recent roundups already cover it, pick a narrower angle, such as the same question for one industry or one budget. A narrow question also makes it easier to find the right experts.
Step 2: Build a list of 20 to 30 experts
List experts who have published real work on the topic in the past year. Look at authors of useful posts, speakers at industry events, and people who answered past roundups. Aim for 20 to 30 names, since only about half will reply, and you want 10 to 15 answers in the final post.
Check each name before you invite them. Read one of their recent posts and note one point you can mention in your email. Skip anyone whose site has no clear author page or contact route, and skip private individuals with no public work. You need people who are used to being quoted in public.
Step 3: Send a short personal invite
Send each expert a short outreach email that names the question, the deadline, and what they get in return. Keep it under 150 words, and mention one specific thing they wrote that you liked. Personalized email bodies earned 32.7% more replies than generic ones in Backlinko's 2019 study of 12 million emails, so a real detail beats a polished template.
Ask for a short answer, a headshot, and a link to their site. Give a deadline 7 to 10 days out, and say you will link to their site and share the post with your audience.
Do not promise a link from a page that does not exist yet, and do not ask them to link back to you in the invite. The ask is for their answer, not for a link.
Step 4: Collect answers and edit lightly
Collect answers in a form or a shared sheet so nothing gets lost. Personalized outreach also lifts replies, so keep each invite specific to the expert. Edit for spelling and clarity only, and keep each expert's wording intact. If an answer is too long, ask the expert if you can trim it, rather than cutting it without telling them.
Group the answers by theme when you have more than 10. Put the strongest or most surprising answers near the top, and add a one-line intro before each answer that says who the expert is. Add a short summary at the end of each theme that states what most experts agreed on and where they differed.
Step 5: Publish with credit and links
Publish the post with each expert's name, role, and a link to their site next to their answer. Link to the expert's own site or their best post on the topic, not to a social profile. Check every link by clicking it, and use the expert's preferred name and title.
Add a short intro that states the question and why it matters, and a short close that sums up the main points of agreement. Keep the page fast to scan with clear subheads, since readers often arrive to find one expert and then read the rest. A clean page also makes it easier for an expert to share it.
Step 6: Tell every expert the post is live
Email every expert on the day the post goes live, including those who did not reply in time. Send the link, thank them, and make sharing easy with a short line they can copy. Most sharing happens in the first 48 hours, so do not wait a week to send this note.
This is also the step where backlinks start to appear. Some experts link to the post from their own blog or press page, and others share it on social channels where other writers see it. You can also ask experts who run newsletters if the post fits a future issue, but accept a no without pushing.
Step 7: Follow up once, then stop
Follow up once with experts who did not reply, about 3 to 4 days after your first email. Keep the follow-up shorter than the first email, restate the deadline, and add one new detail. See how to increase outreach reply rates for more tactics that work the same way.
One follow-up brought 65.8% more replies in Backlinko's 2019 study, so this single nudge is worth sending.
Do not send a third or fourth chase email to the same person. BuzzStream's 2025 study of over 65,000 campaigns and 8 million emails found follow-ups lifted reply rates by 85%, but replies fell 66% after the first follow-up. One polite follow-up protects your reputation and your future invites.
Tools, time and cost
You need only a few tools to run an expert roundup, and most of them are free. A form tool collects answers, a sheet tracks invites and replies, and an email tool sends the invites. Google Search Console, which is free, shows which sites link to the post after it goes live.
| Task | Tool | Cost as of November 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Collect answers | Form tool | Free |
| Track invites | Sheet | Free |
| Send invites | Email tool | Free to paid |
| Check new links | Search Console | Free |
Plan for 2 to 4 weeks from first invite to published post. The invites take a few hours, the wait for answers takes 7 to 10 days, and editing plus publishing takes 1 to 2 days.
Paid outreach tools exist for larger lists, but check the vendor pricing page before you commit, since prices change often. For a first roundup, free tools are enough.
How to measure results
Measure a roundup by new referring domains, not by raw link counts or social shares. A referring domain is one unique site that links to you, so 10 links from one site count as 1 referring domain.
Check the number 2 weeks after launch, then again at 6 weeks, since some experts link late. Track your backlinks on a set schedule so late links are not missed.
Use Google Search Console to check the links. Its Links report shows top linking sites and top linked pages, and its tables are limited to 1,000 rows.
The report is a sample, not a full list of every link, and it does not say if a link is nofollow.
Export up to 100,000 rows of link data from the report landing page for a fuller view, per Google Search Console Help. Run a backlink audit if the numbers look wrong.
Keep the list small to protect your reply rate. BuzzStream's 2025 study of 31 million emails and 86,000 campaigns found campaigns of 51 to 100 emails averaged 12.08 links, while campaigns of 1,001 to 5,000 emails averaged under 3.5 links.
Reply rates fell 68% as lists grew, from 1.15% for lists of 1 to 50 emails to 0.37% for lists of 1,001 to 5,000. A tight list of 20 to 30 experts fits the pattern that works.
Common mistakes
Asking a vague question. A broad question gets broad answers that no one quotes or links to. Fix it by testing the question on one expert first, and rewrite it until the answer fits in 3 sentences.
Inviting too many experts. A list of 200 names turns a personal invite into a mass email, and reply rates fall as lists grow. Keep the list at 20 to 30 names and invite a second group only if you need more answers.
Editing answers into your own voice. Rewriting an expert's words breaks trust and can make them refuse to share the post. Edit for spelling only, and ask before you cut a long answer.
Forgetting to notify experts. A roundup with no launch email earns few shares and few links. Send the live link to every expert on launch day, and follow up once with those who missed it.
Paying for links in the roundup. Buying links is against Google's guidelines, and a paid link that passes ranking credit counts as link spam. Google's spam policies define link spam as links made mainly to manipulate rankings, and say a site that breaks the rules may rank lower or not appear at all. Keep the roundup earned, not bought.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many experts should I invite to a roundup?
Invite 20 to 30 experts for a post with 10 to 15 answers. Only about half of the people you invite will reply, so a list of 20 to 30 gives you enough answers without turning the invite into a mass email.
Start with the experts who fit the question best, and invite a second small group only if you need more answers.
How long should each expert answer be?
Ask for 2 to 4 sentences, or about 40 to 80 words per answer. Short answers keep the post easy to scan and make it simple for readers to compare views. If an expert sends a long answer, ask if you can trim it, and keep their main point and wording intact.
Do experts link back to roundups that feature them?
Some do, and many share the post even when they do not link to it. Experts link when the post is well made, the question is sharp, and their answer is shown fairly with a link to their site.
You cannot force a link, and you should not ask for one in the invite. A good post earns links on its own.
How long does an expert roundup take?
Most roundups take 2 to 4 weeks from first invite to published post. The invites take a few hours, the wait for answers takes 7 to 10 days, and editing plus publishing takes 1 to 2 days. Set the answer deadline at 7 to 10 days out, and publish within a few days of the last answer you accept.
Can I run a roundup without an email tool?
Yes, you can run a small roundup with a plain email account, a form, and a sheet. Email tools help when you send many invites or need to track replies, but a list of 20 to 30 experts is easy to manage by hand.
Use a sheet to track who replied, who needs a follow-up, and who got the launch email.
Sources
- Google Search Central, Spam Policies for Google Web Search (2026)
- Backlinko, We Analyzed 12 Million Outreach Emails (2019)
- BuzzStream, How Effective Is Spray and Pray in PR (2025)
- BuzzStream, Follow-Up Emails in Digital PR (2025)
- Ahrefs, Google Says Links Matter Less (2025)
- Google Search Console Help, Links Report
If you want to compare what paid outreach costs, see our pricing page.
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice TeamRelated guides





