Link Building

20 Questions to Ask a Link Building Agency Before You Hire

By BacklinkPrice Team · Nov 22, 2026 · 6 min read
Illustrated cover for 20 Questions to Ask a Link Building Agency Before You Hire

Twenty questions that reveal how an agency really builds links, what you'll approve, how results are reported, and what happens when a link disappears.

The most important questions to ask a link building agency are how they find and contact sites, whether they pay for placements and how those links are marked, whether you approve every site before it goes live, what a report includes, and what happens if a link is removed.

Good agencies answer clearly and show examples. Vague answers to these questions are the warning signs worth acting on.

Key takeaways

  • Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, so any ranking guarantee deserves a follow-up question.
  • Google's guidance on hiring an SEO tells site owners to avoid link schemes such as buying links that pass ranking credit.
  • An Ahrefs test found 12.6% of contacted sites would sell a link insertion, at an average of $361.44.
  • BuzzStream's 2026 data puts the average link insertion at $179, so pricing questions should cover how placements are sourced.
  • Ask for 10 to 20 recent example links and check them yourself.

The 20 questions at a glance

AreaQuestionsWhat a good answer looks like
Process1–5Clear, repeatable method with real outreach
Paid placements6–8Honest about any payments; sponsored links marked
Quality control9–12You approve sites; clear minimum criteria
Reporting13–15Full URLs, anchors, attributes, dates
Contract and pricing16–20Written terms, replacement period, fair pricing

Questions about process

Understand exactly how links are earned.

  1. How do you find link opportunities? Look for specific tactics: resource pages, digital PR, guest posts on real sites, broken link building.
  2. Who does the outreach? In-house staff, freelancers, or offshore teams? Each can work; secrecy is the issue.
  3. Can you show recent links in my industry? Ask for 10 to 20 live URLs from the last six months.
  4. How long until the first links go live? Realistic answers are weeks, not days.
  5. What content do you create, and who writes it? Guest posts and assets need quality writing.

Read how to check a link building agency's past work to verify example links.

Questions about paid placements

Ask directly; many agencies pay for some links.

  1. Do you pay for any placements? Ahrefs' buy backlinks study found 12.6% of sites it contacted would sell a link insertion, at an average of $361.44. Payments are common, so ask.
  2. Are paid links marked rel="sponsored"? Google's spam policies treat paid links that pass ranking credit as link schemes.
  3. Do you use any private blog networks? The only acceptable answer is no.

BuzzStream's link insertion cost study found an average insertion price of $179 across its database. Compare that with what the agency charges per link to understand its margins and methods.

Questions about quality control

You should be able to check every site.

  1. Can I approve sites before placement? Yes is the right answer.
  2. What are your minimum site criteria? Expect real organic traffic, topical relevance, and an editorial process, not just a DR number.
  3. How do you choose anchor text? Natural, varied anchors are safer than exact-match keywords everywhere.
  4. How do you avoid sites that sell links to anyone? Look for manual checks of outbound links and content quality.

Questions about reporting

Reports should let you verify the work.

  1. What does a monthly report include? Every live link with page URL, anchor, link attributes, and date.
  2. How do you measure success? Referring domains, rankings, and traffic to target pages, not DA charts alone.
  3. How often do you check that links are still live? Monthly checks are a good standard.

Read how to report link building results for a reporting benchmark.

Questions about contracts and pricing

Get the important terms in writing.

  1. What is included in the price per link or per month? Content, outreach, and placement fees.
  2. What happens if a link is removed? A replacement period of six to twelve months is common.
  3. Can I cancel, and with what notice? Avoid long lock-ins without performance terms.
  4. Do you guarantee rankings? Google's guidance on hiring an SEO says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
  5. What access do you need? Usually none to your website; read-only Search Console access is enough for data.

Read link building contracts: what to include for sample clauses.

How to judge the answers

Clarity matters as much as content.

A good agency answers without hesitation, shows real examples, and admits limits such as timelines and the fact that rankings can't be promised. A weak one deflects with metrics, pressure to sign quickly, or "proprietary" methods it won't explain.

PPC Land reported that Google's June 2026 update to its SEO hiring guidance suggests giving only read access to Search Console during audits. Use that as a baseline for any access request.

Ahrefs' article on SEO guarantees explains why ranking guarantees can't be trusted. If an agency offers one, ask how it plans to deliver and what tactics it will use.

Semrush's article on guaranteed SEO makes a similar point: skilled SEOs can improve rankings over time, but no one can change search results at will. Treat honest uncertainty as a good sign, not a weakness.

Compare at least three agencies

Use the same questions with each.

Put each agency's answers in a simple table and score them on transparency, quality control, reporting, and contract terms. Price matters, but only after the other four look solid.

Read how much does a link building agency charge to benchmark pricing.

If you're still deciding whether to hire at all, read in-house vs agency link building.

After you hire

Keep checking, even with a good agency.

Review the first month's links carefully. Check that sites match the criteria you agreed, that paid links are marked, and that anchors look natural. Early problems are easier to fix before a campaign scales.

Agree a quarterly review where you compare links, rankings, and traffic against the goals you set at the start. A good agency welcomes that review; a weak one avoids it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Whether you can approve every site before placement. It reveals how transparent the agency is and lets you check quality yourself.

Yes. Many agencies pay for some placements. The key follow-up is whether those links are marked rel="sponsored".

Ten to twenty recent, live examples, ideally in or near your industry.

Is it a red flag if an agency guarantees rankings?

Yes. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.

Every live link's page URL, anchor text, link attributes, and placement date, plus progress on rankings and traffic for target pages.

Sources

BacklinkPrice Team
Written by
BacklinkPrice Team
Link building and backlink pricing research

The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.

More from BacklinkPrice Team

Related guides