What Is a Good Outreach Reply Rate?

A good outreach reply rate is 4% to 9% of emails sent. Backlinko and Pitchbox found 8.5% of 12 million outreach emails got a reply in 2019.
A good outreach reply rate is 4% to 9% of emails sent, depending on how you count replies. Backlinko and Pitchbox found 8.5% of 12 million outreach emails got a reply in 2019, while Hunter measured 4.5% across full sequences in its 2026 report, so a rate in that range is normal.
Key takeaways
- A reply rate is replies divided by emails sent, times 100, and a reply is not a link.
- Backlinko and Pitchbox found in 2019 that 8.5% of 12 million outreach emails got a reply, so 91.5% got none.
- Hunter measured 4.5% across full sequences in its 2026 report, with digital PR at 13% and sales at 3%.
- One follow-up lifted replies by 65.8% in the Backlinko and Pitchbox 2019 study.
- A rate below 2% usually points to a list, deliverability, or relevance problem, not a subject line problem.
What an outreach reply rate is
An outreach reply rate is the share of outreach emails that get any human reply, shown as a percentage. You divide the number of replies by the number of emails sent, then multiply by 100.
The rate counts every human reply, including a no, a question about price, and a request to stop emailing. It does not count bounces or automatic out-of-office messages, since no person answered. Manual outreach means a person writes and sends each email, rather than a tool sending bulk mail.
Reply rate is not the same as placement rate. A reply only starts a conversation, while a placement means a link went live. Ahrefs polled more than 800 people and found an average conversion rate of only 1% to 5%, so most replies never become links.
What counts as a good reply rate
A good reply rate for link building outreach is about 4% to 9% per email sent, and above 9% is strong. That range covers the two largest datasets, and the table below shows how each study measured it.
| Benchmark | Sample | Reply rate |
|---|---|---|
| Backlinko and Pitchbox, 2019 | 12 million emails | 8.5% |
| Hunter, 2026 | 31 million emails sent in 2025 | 4.5% per sequence |
The second pair of benchmarks shows the same wide spread.
| Benchmark | Sample | Reply rate |
|---|---|---|
| Instantly, 2026 | Billions of emails sent in 2025 | 3.43% |
| Ahrefs poll, 2026 | 800+ people polled | 1% to 5% conversion |
Instantly also shows how wide the spread is. Its 2026 report put the top 25% of senders at 5.5% or more and the top 10% at 10.7% or more, against a 3.43% average. That gap means a good rate is less about one number and more about beating the average by a clear margin.
The studies disagree because they count different things. Backlinko and Pitchbox counted replies per email sent in 2019, while Hunter counted replies per person across a full sequence in 2026. Instantly counted replies per email sent across billions of emails in 2025, and its top 25% of senders reached 5.5% or more.
Your own type of outreach shifts the bar too. Hunter found digital PR averaged 13% in 2026, while sales outreach averaged 3%, so a link building pitch should sit between those two. Set your target from your link building goals and your own past campaigns.
Why reply rate matters and when it applies
Reply rate matters because it is the earliest honest signal that your list and pitch work. Opens can be inflated by automatic loads, but a reply means a person read the email and chose to answer.
The rate applies to cold outreach for links, guest posts, and digital PR, where most recipients have never heard of you. It matters less for warm contacts, past partners, and people who already link to you, since those groups reply far more often. Judge each campaign against similar campaigns, not against a warm list.
Reply rate also sets how many emails a campaign needs. At a 4% reply rate, 100 emails bring about 4 replies, so a campaign that needs 10 replies must send about 250 emails. That math helps you size the list before you start, instead of guessing halfway through.
A low rate also tells you where to fix the campaign. A rate near 0% with high bounces points to bad addresses, while replies that all say no point to a weak offer. Measuring link building ROI starts with this rate, because links come later and hide early problems.
How to calculate and improve your reply rate
Calculate the rate the same way every time, then change one thing at a time and compare. The four steps below give you a baseline you can trust.
Step 1: Count replies and sends the same way
Count unique human replies, not threads, and divide by emails sent, not emails delivered. Record bounces and automatic replies in separate columns so they never inflate the rate. Use one spreadsheet or track your backlinks in the same tool for every campaign.
Step 2: Split the rate by segment
Break the rate down by tactic, niche, and list size before you judge it. Hunter found sequences sent to 21 to 50 people averaged 6.2% in 2026, against 2.4% for sequences sent to more than 500 people. A blended average hides the segment that works.
Step 3: Send one follow-up
Send one short follow-up a few days after the first email, then stop if there is no answer. Backlinko and Pitchbox found one follow-up lifted replies by 65.8% in 2019, and BuzzStream found sequences with follow-ups saw an 85% higher reply rate in 2025. Ahrefs advises sending one follow-up only.
Step 4: Review replies every 100 sends
Read every reply after each 100 emails and sort them into yes, no, price request, and wrong person. If most replies ask for a price, your pitch reads like a paid placement ask. Report link building results with the reply rate beside the placement rate.
Tools and time needed
You need an email finder, a sending tool with sequences, and a spreadsheet or CRM to log replies. Hunter finds addresses and runs sequences, while BuzzStream tracks contacts, sends sequences, and logs replies against each prospect. Compare outreach tools with manual email before you pay for a platform.
Expect about 2 to 4 hours to build a list of 100 prospects, write the pitch, and set up the sequence. Sending and logging replies takes about 30 minutes a day. Check the vendor pricing page before you buy, since plans and limits change, and note the price as of November 2026.
What the evidence says lifts replies
Relevance lifts replies more than any trick, because the recipient must see why your page fits their page. Backlinko and Pitchbox found emails sent to several contacts at one site got 93% more replies than emails sent to one person in 2019. Sequences with several contacts and several messages lifted replies by 160%.
Personalization helps when it shows you read the site. Personalized subject lines got 30.5% more replies, and personalised body copy got 32.7% more replies, in the Backlinko and Pitchbox 2019 study. Subject lines of 36 to 50 characters got the best response rate in the same study.
A known brand can beat the average by a wide margin. Ahrefs ran a campaign of 515 outreach emails and got a 17.55% reply rate and a 5.75% conversion rate. The team put the result down to brand recognition, so a new site should not plan around that number.
Timing and format add smaller gains. Weekday emails got 23.3% more replies than weekend emails in the Backlinko and Pitchbox 2019 study.
BuzzStream found follow-ups sent within 1 day got the best reply rates in 2025. Its first follow-up drew a 1.74% reply rate against 0.59% for the second. Learn how to write a link building outreach email that puts the fit with the recipient page first.
Common mistakes
- Counting opens as replies: open rates are inflated by automatic loads, so a high open rate with no replies means the pitch failed, not the subject line.
- Judging 20 emails: a rate from 20 sends swings with one reply, so wait until you have sent at least 100 emails before you change the pitch.
- Sending endless follow-ups: BuzzStream found the second follow-up drew 66% fewer replies than the first in 2025, so extra messages annoy people without adding links.
- Emailing the wrong person: a reply rate near 0% often means you emailed a generic inbox, so find the editor or author who owns the page.
- Offering payment in the first email: buying links for ranking purposes is against Google's guidelines, and Google's spam policies list buying or selling links for ranking purposes as link spam.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a good outreach reply rate for link building?
A good reply rate is about 4% to 9% per email sent. Backlinko and Pitchbox found 8.5% of 12 million emails got a reply in 2019, and Hunter measured 4.5% across full sequences in 2026. Above 9% is strong, and below 2% means your list, deliverability, or pitch needs work before you send more.
How do you calculate outreach reply rate?
Divide the number of human replies by the number of emails sent, then multiply by 100. Count each person once, and leave out bounces and automatic out-of-office messages. Use the same method for every campaign, since mixing per-email and per-person counts makes the numbers impossible to compare.
Is a 10% reply rate good?
Yes, a 10% reply rate is good and sits above the averages in the largest studies. Instantly found the top 10% of senders reached 10.7% or more in its 2026 report, so 10% puts you near the top. Check that the replies show real interest, since price requests or refusals are not a win.
Why is my outreach reply rate 0%?
A 0% rate usually means emails never reached people or reached the wrong people. Check bounces, spam placement, and whether you emailed a generic inbox instead of the page owner. Also check that your pitch names the page and explains the fit, since a generic ask gives the reader no reason to answer.
How many follow-ups should I send?
Send one follow-up, then stop if there is no reply. Backlinko and Pitchbox found one follow-up lifted replies by 65.8% in 2019, and BuzzStream found the second follow-up drew 66% fewer replies than the first in 2025. Ahrefs also advises one follow-up only, since more messages risk complaints and blocks.
Sources
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice Team




