What Is Grey Hat Link Building? Definition, Examples and Risks

Grey hat link building sits between white hat and black hat tactics. It uses paid posts, link swaps, and niche edits that look editorial but were arranged, and Google can discount them without warning.
Grey hat link building is the practice of building links with tactics that sit between Google's rules and clear spam, such as paid guest posts or small link swaps. The links look editorial, but money, goods, or a return link played a part. That middle ground is the risk: the links can help while they count, then stop without warning.
Key takeaways
- Grey hat link building bends search engine rules without clearly breaking them, using tactics such as paid guest posts, small link swaps, and niche edits.
- Google's December 2022 link spam update used SpamBrain to detect sites buying links and sites used to pass them, and neutralized the credit those links passed (Search Engine Land, 2022).
- Links still track with rankings: in Ahrefs' 2025 study of 1 million keywords, referring domains correlated at 0.255 with rankings, ahead of total backlinks at 0.248.
- In SE Ranking's 2025 study of 129,000 domains, referring domains were the strongest predictor of ChatGPT citations, and sites with over 32,000 referring domains were 3.5 times more likely to be cited.
- When Google discounts grey hat links, the ranking benefit they produced is lost, and Google Search Central states that the lost benefit cannot be regained.
What grey hat link building means
Grey hat link building is link building that uses tactics Google would call unnatural, but that stop short of the most obvious spam, such as link farms or automated link blasts.
The term sits between white hat link building, which earns links through useful content and honest outreach, and black hat work, which relies on deception at scale.
A grey hat link is usually placed because someone paid for it, swapped for it, or arranged it in some other way. The page around it still reads like normal editorial content, which is why the link passes a casual check.
Google does not use the term grey hat in its public documentation. Its updates talk about spammy and unnatural links instead.
How grey hat link building works
Grey hat link building works by placing a link that looks earned while the placement itself was arranged, so the link passes ranking value until Google's systems discount it.
The usual deal is simple. A site owner pays money, sends a free product, or offers a return link, and the other site adds a link inside a real article. Search engines and SEO tools then count that link like any other, and rankings may rise while it counts.
Like all link building, grey hat work only pays off while search engines count the links. Ahrefs' 2025 study of 1 million keywords found referring domains correlated at 0.255 with rankings, with total backlinks at 0.248, so each new linking domain can move a page.
The gain often fades for two reasons. Google's detection keeps improving, and links decay on their own: Ahrefs' 2022 link rot study found 66.5% of links to 2,062,173 sampled websites had rotted since January 2013, and 74.5% were lost for ranking purposes.
Why grey hat link building matters for rankings and AI search
Grey hat link building matters because backlinks still move rankings, and grey hat tactics are a shortcut to getting them. The shortcut is tempting because most pages have almost no links at all.
Backlinko's 2020 study of 11.8 million Google results found about 95% of all pages have zero backlinks. The same study found the top result had 3.8 times more backlinks than positions 2 to 10, and about 3 times more referring domains.
Ahrefs' 2025 study of 1 million keywords put the link effect in numbers: referring domains correlated at 0.255 with rankings, total backlinks at 0.248, and Domain Rating at 0.131.
The link effect has faded over time and varies by query. Referring domains correlated at 0.29 in Ahrefs' 2019 study, against 0.22 to 0.24 in 2025, while local queries still showed 0.33. Ahrefs published both figures in its 2025 study of 1 million keywords.
AI search raises the stakes. In SE Ranking's 2025 study of 129,000 domains and 216,524 pages, referring domains were the strongest predictor of ChatGPT citations. Sites with over 32,000 referring domains were 3.5 times more likely to be cited than sites with up to 200.
That link between authority and AI citations is why grey hat links look attractive.
Real examples of grey hat link building
The most common grey hat tactics share one trait: the link looks editorial, but an exchange sits behind it.
- Paid guest posts: you pay a site to publish your article, and the article links back to you without a sponsored label. The post reads like normal content, but the placement was bought.
- Niche edits: you pay to add your link into an old article that already ranks. The link gains the page's existing authority, and no new content is created.
- Small link swaps: two or three sites agree to link to each other. Each swap looks harmless on its own, but a pattern of swaps is easy for Google's systems to spot.
- Sponsored posts without a label: a brand pays for a review or a mention, and the link passes ranking value because it carries no sponsored or nofollow attribute.
- Keyword-rich anchors in paid posts: the bought link uses exact-match commercial anchor text, such as a money keyword, instead of a brand name or a plain URL.
- Paid directory listings: you pay for a listing on a directory that exists mainly to sell links. The listing adds little for readers, and the link is the product.
How to check or measure grey hat links
You can check for grey hat links by auditing who links to you, how those links were placed, and whether the pattern looks arranged.
- Export your backlinks from Google Search Console or an SEO tool, then sort them by referring domain so one site with many links does not hide the pattern.
- Read the anchor text. A cluster of identical commercial anchors pointing at one page is a sign the links were arranged, not earned.
- Open the linking pages. Check whether they link out to many unrelated sites, run a public "write for us" page that sells posts, or publish paid content without labels.
- Track referring domains, not raw link counts. Backlinko's 2020 study of 11.8 million results found the top result had about 3 times more referring domains than positions 2 to 10.
- Re-check lost links each quarter. Ahrefs' 2022 link rot study found 66.5% of links to sampled sites had rotted since January 2013, so paid links on weak sites often vanish.
- Clean up what you find. Ask the site to remove a paid link first, and if that fails, use Google's Disavow Tool to ask Google to ignore it.
Measure the result by referring domains, rankings, referral traffic, and AI citations. If referring domains rise but rankings do not, the links are probably not counting.
The risks of grey hat link building
Grey hat links can help rankings while Google counts them, but the risk is that Google discounts them silently, so you pay for value that disappears. Google's December 2022 link spam update made that silent discount the normal outcome for paid links.
Search Engine Land reported in 2022 that the update took about two weeks to roll out and applied in all languages. Google said SpamBrain could now detect both sites buying links and sites used to pass outgoing links.
Google's 2022 webspam report showed how fast that detection grew. Search Engine Land reported in 2023 that SpamBrain caught 5 times more spam sites than in 2021, and 200 times more than at its 2018 launch, while the December 2022 update detected 50 times more link spam sites than the July 2021 update.
Penguin set the pattern long before SpamBrain. Google announced on September 23, 2016 that Penguin was real-time and more granular, devaluing spam links instead of demoting whole sites. Penguin first launched in 2012, and Google counts it among more than 200 ranking signals.
The harshest part is that the loss is final. Google Search Central states that when its systems remove the effects of spammy links, any ranking benefit those links produced is lost, and it cannot be regained.
| Approach | How the link is earned | How Google treats it as of November 2026 | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| White hat | Earned through useful content and honest outreach | Counts as a normal editorial link | Slow growth |
| Grey hat | Arranged through payment, goods, or a swap | Discounted when detected, and the credit is removed | Paid value vanishes without warning |
| Black hat | Built with link farms, hacked pages, or automation | Treated as spam, and the site may rank lower or vanish | Manual action or removal from results |
Common mistakes and myths
The most common grey hat mistakes come from treating a short-term gain as a lasting asset. Since Google Penguin became real-time in 2016, Google discounts spammy links as it recrawls pages.
- Buying in bulk: pointing dozens of paid links at one page with the same anchor text creates a pattern that is easy to spot. Spread links across pages, or better, do not buy them at all.
- Trusting a seller's promise: no vendor can promise that Google will never detect a paid link. The December 2022 link spam update detected 50 times more link spam sites than the July 2021 update (Search Engine Land, 2023).
- Counting links instead of referring domains: 50 links from one site still count as one referring domain. Backlinko's 2020 study found the top result had about 3 times more referring domains than positions 2 to 10.
- Ignoring link rot: paid links often sit on weak sites that vanish. Ahrefs' 2022 study found 66.5% of links to sampled sites had rotted since January 2013, with 47.7% lost because the linking page was dropped.
- Myth: Google cannot detect paid links. Google's SpamBrain system has detected link spam since the December 2022 update, and its 2022 webspam report showed 5 times more spam sites caught than in 2021 (Search Engine Land, 2023).
- Myth: a penalty is the worst outcome. The common outcome is silent: the links stop counting, the ranking gain is lost, and Google states that the lost benefit cannot be regained.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is grey hat link building illegal?
No. Grey hat link building is not a crime, but it breaks Google's spam rules. Google can discount the links, rank the site lower, or remove it from results. The risk is lost search visibility and wasted spend, not a fine or a court case.
Can grey hat links get my site penalized?
Yes. Google can apply a manual action for unnatural links, or its systems can discount the links without telling you. Google states that when spammy links are neutralized, any ranking benefit they produced is lost and that lost benefit cannot be regained.
How is grey hat link building different from black hat link building?
Grey hat tactics bend the rules while looking editorial, such as a paid guest post on a real site. Black hat tactics use deception at scale, such as link farms, hacked pages, and automated link blasts. Both break Google's rules, but black hat work is easier for Google to spot.
Do grey hat links still work in 2026?
They can work while Google counts them. Ahrefs' 2025 study of 1 million keywords found referring domains still correlated at 0.255 with rankings. But detection keeps growing: the December 2022 link spam update detected 50 times more link spam sites than the July 2021 update.
Should I disavow grey hat links I bought?
If you want to lower the risk, ask the linking site to remove the paid link first. If that fails, Google's Disavow Tool lets you ask Google to ignore it. Be careful: Ahrefs' own test showed traffic fell after it disavowed all links to three of its posts.
Sources
- Google Search Central: Penguin is now part of our core algorithm (2016)
- Google Search Central: Google Search spam updates and your site (2026)
- Search Engine Land: Google releases December 2022 link spam update (2022)
- Search Engine Land: Google webspam report: SpamBrain caught 5x more spam (2023)
- Backlinko: We Analyzed 11.8 Million Google Search Results (2020)
- SE Ranking: How to Optimize for ChatGPT (2025)
- Ahrefs: Google Says "Links Matter Less" (2025)
- Ahrefs: At Least 66.5% of Links to Sites in the Last 9 Years Are Dead (2022)
If you want links that last, start with how to build backlinks the white hat way.
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice TeamRelated guides





