What to Do When a Site Changes Your Link to Nofollow?

When a site changes your link to nofollow, keep the link, check what changed in the HTML, and ask for the follow version only when the link was earned.
When a site changes your link to nofollow, keep the link, check what changed, and ask for the follow version only when the link was earned. The change usually costs ranking credit, but the link can still send readers, and Google may still use it as a hint. A check, a note, and a better page fix most cases.
Key takeaways
- Google has treated nofollow as a hint, not an order, since 10 September 2019, and as a hint for crawling and indexing since 1 March 2020 (Google Search Central Blog, 2019).
- A nofollow link generally passes no direct ranking credit, but it still sends referral traffic and Google may still use it in some cases.
- Semrush's 2025 study of 1,000 domains found nofollow links correlate with AI mentions almost the same as follow links, at Pearson 0.340 against 0.334.
- Check the link in the page HTML first, because a tool can report a change that came from a sitewide policy, not from your link alone.
- Ask the editor for a follow link only when the link was earned, the content still fits, and you can point to a clear reason.
What a nofollow change means
A nofollow link is a link with rel="nofollow" in its HTML, which tells Google not to treat it as a normal endorsement. Google introduced the value in 2005 to fight comment spam, and it now sits beside two newer values, sponsored and ugc.
The change means the linking site still points at your page, but it no longer vouches for it in the usual way.
Sites change a link to nofollow for many reasons, and most have nothing to do with your page. A site may switch all outbound links to nofollow, change its guest post policy, or add the value during an update. What is a nofollow link explains the value itself and how it differs from a normal link.
The first job is to work out whether the change hit one link or every link on the site. One changed link may point to a deal you made, a page update, or a single editor decision.
A sitewide change points to a new policy, and asking about one link will not undo it. Check a few other outbound links on the same site before you write to anyone.
Why a nofollow change matters
The ranking loss is real but small
A nofollow link usually stops passing direct ranking credit to your page. Google says links marked with these values will generally not be followed, so the vote the link once gave is gone in most cases. Dofollow vs nofollow links sets out the difference in full, and why a normal link still carries more weight.
The loss is smaller than many guides claim, because a nofollow link keeps three kinds of value. It still sends readers who click it, it still puts your brand in front of a new audience, and Google treats it as a hint it may use.
AI search values the link more
A link on a page people actually read can be worth more than a follow link on a page no one visits. Google said: "All the link attributes — sponsored, UGC and nofollow — are treated as hints about which links to consider or exclude within Search." (Google Search Central Blog, 2019).
AI search softens the blow further. Semrush's 2025 study of 1,000 domains tracked mentions across 5 AI platforms, ChatGPT, ChatGPT with Search, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, and Perplexity. Nofollow links had a Pearson correlation of 0.340 with AI mentions, next to 0.334 for follow links, and Spearman values of 0.509 and 0.504. (Semrush study)
Authority matters more than the label. The same Semrush study found Authority Score had a Pearson correlation of 0.65 with AI mentions, far above the follow and nofollow figures. That result points to the same fix as classic search: earn links from trusted, relevant sites, and do not judge a single link by its rel value alone.
What to do, step by step
Step 1: Confirm the change in the page HTML
Open the linking page in your browser, right-click the link, and choose Inspect to read the HTML. Look at the rel value on the anchor tag: nofollow, sponsored, and ugc are three different values, and each calls for a different reply. How to check if a backlink is dofollow walks through the same check in more detail.
Check the date too. Compare the live page with your record of when the link was placed and what it looked like then. If you have no record, check the page in a backlink tool and note the date the change first appeared. A change made during a redesign is often a policy shift, not a verdict on your page.
Step 2: Work out what you lost and what you kept
A changed link is not always a lost link, so sort it before you act. Check whether the link still sends clicks, whether the page still ranks, and whether the linking page still gets traffic. How to monitor lost links shows how to watch a link over time instead of guessing from one check.
Use this check to sort the change before you write to anyone.
| What changed | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Only your link | One editor decision | Ask about that link |
| All outbound links | New site policy | Do not chase it |
| Link removed too | Link is gone | Ask for a new placement |
Step 3: Ask for the follow version, when it fits
Write to the editor only when the link was earned and the page still fits. Say what changed, link to the page, and ask whether the follow version can be restored.
Should guest post links be nofollow covers when a paid link should stay qualified, so do not ask for a follow link on a placement you paid for.
Keep the note short, polite, and specific, and send it once. Give the editor the exact URL of your link, the date it changed if you know it, and one reason the follow version fits.
If the editor says no, or does not reply in 2 weeks, accept it and move on. Chasing one link for months costs more than the link is worth.
Do not offer payment to flip the value. Google's spam policies list buying or selling links for ranking purposes as link spam, and a paid link is only safe when it carries nofollow or sponsored. (Google spam policies)
A follow link bought from an editor puts both sites at risk, and the link can be removed later anyway.
Step 4: Strengthen the page the link points to
If the follow version will not come back, make the target page worth more on its own. Improve the content, add a fresh fact or example, and earn a second link from another site. How to recover lost backlinks covers the wider fix for links that change or disappear, including when to rebuild the link elsewhere.
A nofollow link can still start a chain that ends in a follow link. Ahrefs describes how a nofollow link on a busy Q and A page led a reader to write a new article with a follow link.
Keep the page easy to find and cite, so readers who arrive through the link can still pass it on. (Ahrefs)
Tools, time and cost
You need no paid tool to check one link: a browser and the Inspect command are enough. For a whole profile, a backlink tool saves hours, and Ahrefs' free tier shows 1,000 backlinks at once for a site you verify.
Paid plans start at Lite, $129 a month, as of November 2026, which is more than most single-link checks need. (Ahrefs pricing)
Budget about 30 minutes to check one link and write one note to the editor. A full check of a profile takes 2 to 4 hours, spread over a week, so you can watch for more changes. The suggested split below covers a small review of 20 links with no paid tool.
| Task | Suggested time | Suggested cost |
|---|---|---|
| Check 20 links | 1 hour | $0 |
| Write 5 notes | 1 hour | $0 |
| Recheck in 2 weeks | 30 minutes | $0 |
Times are suggested allocations, not measured averages.
How to measure the result
Measure the link, not your feelings about it. Track referral visits from the linking page, the target page's rankings for its main keyword, and the number of follow links the page earns over the next 3 months. How to know if a backlink is helping gives the full check for judging one link by its results.
Give the change 4 to 6 weeks before you judge it. Rankings move slowly, and one nofollow change rarely moves a page on its own. Compare the target page with similar pages that kept their links, so a sitewide shift does not look like a link problem. If the page holds its place, the link was not doing much work.
Watch for a second-hand win too. A nofollow mention on a trusted site can bring readers who later link to you from their own sites, and Semrush's 2025 study found Authority Score had a Pearson correlation of 0.65 with AI mentions.
Count new follow links and new brand mentions over 3 months, not just the one link that changed. (Semrush study)
Common mistakes
- Demanding the link back: a harsh note burns the contact and the link, and the editor may remove the link entirely instead of changing its value.
- Paying to flip the value: buying a follow link breaks Google's spam policies, and a paid link must carry nofollow or sponsored to stay within the rules.
- Nofollowing everything in reply: changing your own outbound links to nofollow does not punish the other site, and it weakens your own pages.
- Treating nofollow as noindex: a nofollow link does not keep a page out of Google, and the page can still be crawled through a sitemap or another link.
- Checking once and stopping: a site can change a link back, or change more links later, so recheck the links that matter every month.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a nofollow link still help my rankings?
Rarely, and never in the way a follow link does. Google has treated nofollow as a hint since 10 September 2019, so it may use the link in some cases, but it said it will generally treat such links as before and not count them for ranking. The link still sends readers, and it can lead to follow links later.
Should I ask the site to change it back?
Yes, when the link was earned, the content still fits, and you have a clear reason to give. Send one short, polite note with the exact link URL and ask whether the follow version can be restored. If the link was paid for, do not ask: a paid link must carry nofollow or sponsored under Google's spam policies.
Does a nofollow link still send traffic?
Yes. The rel value changes how search engines read the link, not what happens when a reader clicks it. A nofollow link on a page people read can send steady visits, and those visitors may link to you from their own sites. Check the referral visits in your analytics before you judge the link.
How do I know if the whole site changed its policy?
Inspect a few other outbound links on the same site. If every link carries nofollow, sponsored, or ugc, the site has a blanket policy, and one note about your link will not change it. If only your link changed, the cause is more likely a single edit, and a note to the editor is worth sending.
Can I disavow a link that turned nofollow?
No, there is no need. A nofollow link already tells Google not to pass ranking credit, so disavowing it adds nothing. A nofollow link is not a penalty, and it does not hurt your site on its own. Keep the link and watch what it sends instead.
Sources
If you want to keep track of the links that matter, see how to track backlinks for a simple routine.
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice TeamRelated guides





