Why Do Backlink Tools Show Different Numbers?

Backlink tools show different numbers because each tool crawls a different slice of the web and counts links by its own rules. No two tools share a crawler, an index, or a scoring formula.
Backlink tools show different numbers because each tool crawls a different slice of the web and counts links by its own rules. No two tools share a crawler, an index, or a scoring formula, so the same site gets a different backlink count, a different referring domain count, and a different authority score in each tool.
Key takeaways
- Semrush reports more than 43 trillion backlinks and 390 million referring domains, while Ahrefs reports 35 trillion backlinks.
- Ahrefs Domain Rating uses links only, Moz Domain Authority is a ranking model, and Semrush adds spam checks.
- Search Console shows a sample of links, not a full list, and its tables stop at 1,000 rows.
- New links can appear in Semrush within about an hour, while authority scores can lag by days or weeks.
- Compare a site with itself over time in one tool, and judge it by referring domains rather than raw backlink totals.
Why the counts never match
The counts never match because each tool crawls the web on its own, stores what it finds in its own index, and counts links by its own rules. Two tools can look at the same site on the same day and report different totals.
Think of each tool as a separate survey of the web, not a shared record. A link counts only when that tool's crawler has found the linking page and kept it in the index. Our comparison of Ahrefs DR vs Moz DA vs Semrush AS shows how far apart the three scores can sit.
Crawl coverage also varies by site type. Some publishers block certain crawlers in robots.txt, so those links never enter that tool's index. A tool strong on blogs can still be thin on forums and new sites, and the gaps show up as different totals.
Each tool crawls a different web
Each vendor publishes its own index size, and the figures show how different the crawls are. Semrush says its index holds more than 43 trillion backlinks and 390 million referring domains, and its database is refreshed at least hourly (Semrush). New links typically appear in under 24 hours, and often within about an hour.
Ahrefs reports 35 trillion backlinks in its index, with fresh data added every 15 to 30 minutes (Ahrefs). The 8 trillion gap between the two headline figures is not a mistake, since the vendors count different things.
Majestic keeps two indexes instead of one. Its Fresh Index lists links seen in the past 120 days, while its Historic Index reaches back to 2006 (Majestic). A link from 2015 can appear in Majestic and be absent from a tool that keeps only recent links.
| Tool | Index size | Refresh |
|---|---|---|
| Ahrefs | 35 trillion backlinks | Every 15 to 30 minutes |
| Semrush | 43 trillion backlinks | At least hourly |
| Majestic | Fresh Index, past 120 days | At least daily |
Backlinks and referring domains are counted differently
A backlink is one link, while a referring domain is one site that links to you, however many links it sends. Our guide to backlinks vs referring domains explains the split, and the split matters because tools deduplicate links in different ways.
One tool may count every link on a page, while another counts only one link per linking domain. A site with 500 links from 10 domains can therefore show 500 backlinks in one tool and a far smaller referring domain total in both. A sitewide footer link repeats the count on hundreds of pages.
Nofollow links add another split. Some tools count them in the backlink total but leave them out of authority scores, while others filter them earlier. What a referring domain is gives the base unit to watch, since one new referring domain usually tells you more than 10 extra links from a site that already links to you.
Lost links cause more drift. A tool drops a link only after its crawler rechecks the page and finds it gone, so dead links can sit in one index for weeks after another tool has removed them.
Authority scores use different formulas
Each authority score is a vendor formula, not a Google number. Ahrefs Domain Rating runs from 0 to 100 on a logarithmic scale and uses links only, so traffic, spam, and domain age are not inputs. How Domain Rating is calculated walks through the three inputs: linking domains, their scores, and how many sites each one links to.
Moz Domain Authority also runs from 1 to 100, but it is a machine learning model trained on search results, and it weighs linking root domains, total links, and spam signals. How Domain Authority is calculated covers the method, and Moz rebuilt the model as Domain Authority 2.0 in March 2019 (Shopify).
Semrush Authority Score runs from 1 to 100 too, but it mixes link power with estimated organic traffic and spam checks, and Semrush recalculates it every 2 weeks. A site can therefore hold the same links and still see its Semrush score move while its Ahrefs score stays flat.
Majestic splits the job in two, with Trust Flow for link quality and Citation Flow for link volume, each from 0 to 100. Two tools can agree on the links and still disagree on the score, because the score is a model built on the links, not the links themselves.
What Google says and what Search Console shows
Google does not publish an authority score, and it does not use Domain Rating, Domain Authority, or Authority Score in ranking. Google's spam policies define link spam as creating links mainly to manipulate rankings, and buying or selling links for ranking purposes is listed as an example (Google Search Central).
Sites that break the rules may rank lower or not appear in results at all, and paid links are not a violation when they carry rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored". That rule covers ranking credit, not tool counts. It does explain why a paid link can sit in a tool's index while Google gives it no weight.
Google Search Console shows links from Google's own crawl, but only for sites you have verified, and the report is a sample rather than a full list. Its tables stop at 1,000 rows, and it does not show whether a link is nofollow (Google Search Console Help). Use it to check your strongest links.
When the gaps are normal and when they are not
Different totals are normal for most sites, because each index misses a different slice of the web. Small sites show the widest gaps, since a handful of missed links is a large share of a small total.
A sudden drop in one tool while the others stay flat is worth a look. Check whether the tool lost a large linking site, changed how it counts, or updated its index, before you assume your links are gone.
A drop across every tool at once points to a real loss, such as a deleted page, a removed sitewide link, or a domain that went offline.
What to do in practice
Pick one tool as your record and stick with it. Track the trend in that tool month to month, and use the others only for spot checks. How to check backlinks of any website shows where each tool prints its count, so you compare the same report each time instead of mixing reports.
Compare referring domains first and backlink totals second. Referring domains move slowly and resist inflation from sitewide links. When you report progress, give the tool name, the date, and the referring domain count.
Cross-check your best links in Search Console, since it shows what Google has processed for your own site. If an editorial link from a strong site appears in Search Console and in your main tool, trust it. If a link appears only in one paid tool, treat it as unconfirmed until a second source sees it.
Common mistakes
- Comparing scores across tools: a Domain Rating of 45 and a Domain Authority of 45 are different numbers. Compare each score only with its own past values.
- Chasing the highest count: the biggest total is not the most accurate one. A bigger index can hold more dead links, so a bigger number can mean older data.
- Checking once and deciding: a single same-day check catches tools at different points in their refresh cycles. Check again after 2 weeks.
- Ignoring lost links: a falling backlink count can mean a tool cleaned up dead links, not that you lost real ones. Look at the lost links report first.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which backlink tool has the most accurate numbers?
No tool is the most accurate in every case, because each one measures its own crawl rather than the full web. Semrush reports the largest index at more than 43 trillion backlinks, while Ahrefs reports 35 trillion. Use one tool for trends and Search Console to confirm what Google has seen.
Why did my backlink count drop overnight?
A sharp drop usually means the tool updated its index or removed dead links, not that your site lost real links overnight. A tool drops a link only after a recrawl confirms it is gone. Check the referring domain count before you worry.
Should I trust Domain Rating, Domain Authority, or Authority Score?
Trust each score only inside its own tool, since they measure different things with different formulas. Domain Rating uses links only, Domain Authority uses a machine learning model, and Authority Score adds traffic and spam checks. Never mix the scores in one table.
Does Google Search Console show all my backlinks?
No, Search Console shows a sample of links rather than a full list, and its tables stop at 1,000 rows. It covers only sites you have verified, and it does not show whether a link is nofollow. Use it to confirm your best links.
Sources
- Semrush: Free Backlink Checker (2026)
- Google Search Central: Spam Policies for Google Web Search (2026)
- Ahrefs: Ahrefs SEO Metrics, A Glossary (2026)
- Majestic: The Majestic Backlink Indexes (no date shown)
- Google Search Console Help: Links report (no date shown)
- Shopify: Domain Authority, How to Check and Improve It (2026)
If you want a repeatable check on your own profile, run a backlink audit in one tool and track the same numbers each month.
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice TeamRelated guides





