Outreach

Broken Link Building Email Template (5 Versions That Get Replies)

By BacklinkPrice Team · Nov 22, 2026 · 6 min read
Illustrated cover for Broken Link Building Email Template (5 Versions That Get Replies)

Five copy-ready broken link building emails, from the short heads-up to the follow-up, plus subject lines, personalisation tips and reply-rate data.

A good broken link building email tells the editor exactly which link is broken and where, offers a relevant working replacement, and keeps the ask small. The best versions are under 120 words, name the page and the dead URL, and never assume the editor owes you a link.

Below are five templates you can adapt, plus subject lines and the data behind them.

Key takeaways

  • Backlinko and Pitchbox found 91.5% of outreach emails are ignored, so specific, useful emails stand out.
  • BuzzStream's study of 31 million emails found an average reply rate of 0.85%, higher for small campaigns.
  • Broken link emails work because they start with a favour: a fix the editor can make quickly.
  • Name the exact page, the dead link, and where it appears.
  • Send one follow-up, then stop.

Which template to use

TemplateUse whenLength
1. Short heads-upYou want a reply before pitching50–70 words
2. Replacement offerYou have a strong matching resource80–120 words
3. Multi-link reportThe page has several broken links100–140 words
4. Follow-upNo reply after 4–7 days30–50 words
5. Thank-youThe link goes live30–50 words

You lead with help, not a request.

Broken link building means finding dead links on relevant pages and suggesting your content as a replacement. Read what is broken link building for the full process.

Backlinko's email outreach study of 12 million emails found 91.5% get no reply. A specific, helpful note is one of the few ways to stand out.

Volume hurts. A summary of BuzzStream data by AirOps reports a 0.85% average reply rate across 31 million emails, with campaigns of 1–50 emails averaging 1.15% versus 0.37% for 1,001–5,000.

Template 1: The short heads-up

Ask permission before you pitch.

Subject: Broken link on your {{page topic}} page

Hi {{first name}},

I was reading "{{page title}}" and noticed the link to {{dead site or resource}} in the {{section}} section returns a 404.

Would you like me to send a couple of possible replacements?

{{your name}}

This version gets replies because it asks for nothing but a "yes". Send your resource only when they respond.

Template 2: The replacement offer

Best when your page is a strong, close match.

Subject: Quick fix for "{{page title}}"

Hi {{first name}},

Your guide "{{page title}}" links to {{dead URL}} for {{topic}}, but that page now returns an error.

The second part offers the fix:

We recently published {{your resource title}}, which covers the same {{topic}} with {{what is new, e.g. 2026 data}}: {{your URL}}

It could be a quick replacement if it fits. Either way, I hope the heads-up helps.

{{your name}}

More help, more goodwill.

Subject: 3 broken links on your {{topic}} resource page

Hi {{first name}},

I was using your {{topic}} resource page and found three links that no longer work:

  • {{dead link 1}}
  • {{dead link 2}}
  • {{dead link 3}}

Then add one suggestion, not three:

For the second one, our {{resource}} covers the same topic and could work as a replacement: {{your URL}}

Thanks for keeping such a useful list.

Read how to write a link building outreach email for more structure tips.

Template 4: The follow-up

Once, politely, after four to seven days.

Subject: Re: Broken link on your {{page topic}} page

Hi {{first name}}, just bumping this in case it got buried. The broken link is in the {{section}} of "{{page title}}". No worries if you've already fixed it.

See how to follow up on outreach emails for timing.

Template 5: The thank-you

Build the relationship for next time.

Hi {{first name}}, thanks for updating the link. If you ever need data or a quote on {{topic}} for a future piece, I'm happy to help.

When to send and how fast replies come

Most replies arrive the same day.

BuzzStream's reply timing study found 57% of link building replies arrive within six hours, with an average response time of 12.85 hours. Check your inbox often on send days and reply quickly while the editor is still at their desk.

Before sending, find the right person. An editor or author converts far better than a generic contact form; see how to find email addresses for outreach.

  • Broken link on your {{topic}} page
  • Quick fix for "{{page title}}"
  • 404 on your {{topic}} resource list
  • Dead link in your {{topic}} guide

Keep them specific and plain. Backlinko's study found longer subject lines of 36 to 50 characters got higher response rates than very short ones.

Personalisation that actually matters

Show you visited the page.

  • Name the exact section or paragraph with the dead link.
  • Mention what the dead page used to cover.
  • Explain in one line why your page is a fair replacement.
  • Use the editor's name, not "webmaster".

Read how to increase outreach reply rates for more.

How Ahrefs used this approach

A real example from a well-known SEO team.

Ahrefs' link outreach guide shows an email it sent as part of a broken link building campaign and recommends following up once.

Its email outreach experiment reports 111 emails sent with a 41% response rate after manually reviewing about 200 prospects. Careful prospect selection did most of the work.

Different situations need different wording.

Broken link emails point out someone else's dead link and offer your page. Link reclamation emails ask a site to fix a broken link that was meant to point to you. Read link reclamation vs broken link building.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Not naming where the broken link is.
  • Pitching a page that doesn't match the dead resource.
  • Sending the same template to hundreds of sites.
  • Following up three or more times.
  • Asking for a link before confirming the editor cares.

Compliance basics

Keep it honest and easy to opt out.

The FTC's CAN-SPAM compliance guide requires honest subject lines and a way to opt out for commercial email in the US. Check local rules for other countries.

Frequently Asked Questions

The page title, where the broken link appears, the dead URL, a relevant replacement, and a short, polite ask.

Under 120 words is a good target. The short heads-up version can be 50 to 70 words.

Either works. Asking permission first often gets more replies; including the link saves a step when your resource is a very close match.

How many follow-ups should I send?

One, four to seven days after the first email.

It varies widely. Small, well-targeted campaigns can reach double-digit reply rates, while large untargeted ones often get below 1%.

Sources

BacklinkPrice Team
Written by
BacklinkPrice Team
Link building and backlink pricing research

The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.

More from BacklinkPrice Team

Related guides