Link Reclamation vs Broken Link Building: What's the Difference?

Link reclamation recovers links you already had, while broken link building wins new links from other sites' dead pages. Here is how they differ, when to use each, and what each one costs.
Link reclamation recovers links you already had, while broken link building wins new links from other sites' dead pages. Reclamation starts with your own backlink profile and fixes what broke. Broken link building starts with dead pages on other sites and offers your page as a replacement. Both tactics fix broken links, but they chase different links.
Key takeaways
- Link reclamation targets links you once had. Ahrefs defines it as reclaiming lost links. Ahrefs lists 4 common loss reasons: link removed, linking page deleted, linking page redirected, and linking page noindexed.
- Broken link building targets dead pages on other sites. Ahrefs calls it the fifth most used link building tactic, based on Aira's report from 270 SEOs in 2022.
- Link rot is common. Ahrefs' 2022 study of 2,062,173 sites found 66.5% of links had rotted since January 2013, and 74.5% counted as lost in total.
- Outreach replies are scarce. Backlinko and Pitchbox found in 2019 that only 8.5% of 12 million outreach emails got a reply, while one follow-up added 65.8% more replies.
- Reclamation is usually faster and cheaper because the link already existed. Broken link building needs new content, but it can add links from sites that never linked to you.
The core difference
Link reclamation gets back a link you already earned, while broken link building earns a link you never had.
Link reclamation is the process of reclaiming lost links. Ahrefs defines it in one line: you had a link, you lost it, and you want it back. The work starts in your own backlink data.
You find why each link vanished, then fix the cause or ask for the link back. See link reclamation for the loss reasons.
Broken link building is a tactic that takes advantage of broken pages on the web. It involves finding a dead page and asking linkers to swap the links to a working page on your site. The dead page belongs to someone else. Your page must match it well enough to earn the swap.
The two tactics get mixed up because both deal with dead links and both use outreach. The split is ownership.
Reclamation fixes links that pointed to your site. Broken link building fixes links that pointed to a dead page elsewhere. Pew Research Center found in 2024 that 25% of web pages from 2013 to 2023 were no longer accessible.
Side-by-side comparison
Reclamation is a fix for your own profile, while broken link building is a hunt for new links on other sites.
| Factor | Link reclamation | Broken link building |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | Links you already had | Dead pages on other sites |
| Target | Sites that linked to you | Sites that linked to the dead page |
| New content needed | Rarely, a redirect often fixes it | Usually, you must build a replacement page |
| Main first step | Check your lost links report | Find dead pages with backlinks |
| Outreach | Short note to a site that knows you | Cold pitch to a site that does not know you |
| Time to first win | Days, when a redirect fixes many links | Weeks, after content and outreach |
| Best for | Sites with an older backlink profile | Sites with strong content and few links |
The table shows the trade-off. Reclamation is narrow and fast because the site already linked to you. Broken link building is broad and slow because you must find dead pages, build a match, and persuade strangers. Ahrefs' 2022 link rot study found 47.7% of lost links sat on dropped pages and 34.2% had been removed.
How link reclamation works
Link reclamation works by finding lost links, sorting them by why they vanished, and fixing each cause.
- Find your lost links in a backlink tool. In Ahrefs Site Explorer, open Backlinks and choose Lost to see links lost in the past 30 days. For ahrefs.com, that list held 6,285 lost links, cut to 594 by the best-links filter.
- Sort each loss by its reason. A removed link is often worth pursuing, and a deleted linking page is sometimes worth pursuing. A noindex tag or a changed canonical is probably not worth pursuing.
- Fix what you can on your own site first. Redirect each dead URL that still has backlinks to the closest live page, not to your homepage. Our guide to fixing broken backlinks walks through the redirect step.
- Email the linking site only when their help is needed. Keep the note short, name the page, and say what changed. A removed link after a content refresh is a fair ask.
Semrush tracks the same problem in its Backlink Audit tool. Its Lost and Found report shows new, lost, and broken referring domains each day over the last 90 days. Semrush says lost domains are ones you lost backlinks from within the past 3 months. See how to recover lost backlinks.
How broken link building works
Broken link building works in 4 steps: find dead pages with backlinks, vet them, build a replacement, and ask linkers to swap.
- Find dead pages with backlinks. Check a rival site in Ahrefs Site Explorer, open Best by links, and filter for 404 pages. Ahrefs found 134 dead pages on Content Marketing Institute's site, and some had backlinks from over 50 referring domains.
- Search by topic as well as by rival. In Ahrefs Content Explorer, search a broad topic and filter for broken pages with at least 20 referring domains. Ahrefs found 188 broken pages about content marketing that met that bar.
- Vet the links before you build anything. Check that the dead page has dofollow links. Ahrefs suggests filters of DR 5 or higher and domain traffic of 20 or higher. Those filters cut one list of 100 backlinks to 29.
- Build a replacement that matches the dead page. Use the Wayback Machine to see what the old page covered, then write a page that serves the same purpose. Fix any facts that are now out of date.
- Do outreach that leads with the dead link. Name the broken page, show the exact link, and offer your page as the fix. Send one follow-up if you hear nothing.
When to use each
Use reclamation first when you have an older site with lost links, and use broken link building when you need new referring domains.
- Use reclamation after a redesign or migration, when old URLs may have lost their redirects. Check your lost links report in the first week after the move.
- Use reclamation after a content refresh, when an update may have dropped links that pointed to a page you changed.
- Use broken link building when you launch a strong new guide and need links from sites that never linked to you.
- Use broken link building when you enter a niche with many old resource pages. Resource pages are rarely updated, so they often link to dead resources.
- Use both when you run a regular link audit. Reclamation protects what you have, and broken link building adds what you lack.
A broken backlink is a link that points to a page on your site that returns an error. That case sits inside reclamation, but broken link building starts from dead pages that belong to other sites.
SEO impact of each
Both tactics can restore or add ranking value, but reclamation protects value you already earned and broken link building adds new referring domains.
A reclaimed link restores an existing vote from a site that already chose to link to you. The anchor text and page context stay close to the original, so the value returns in a familiar form. A noindexed linking page is the exception, since Ahrefs notes that a noindexed page probably passes less value.
A broken link building win adds a new referring domain, which is a site that had never linked to you before. That matters because a new domain adds a fresh vote rather than repeating one you already had. The size of the gain depends on the dead page, so vetting is the step that decides the result.
Pew Research Center found in 2024 that 23% of news web pages contain at least one broken link, and 21% of government web pages do too. That supply keeps both tactics alive. The link equity at stake is the ranking value a link passes, and both tactics aim to keep that value flowing to a live page.
Cost and effort compared
Reclamation costs less time and money than broken link building because most fixes are redirects or short emails.
Reclamation needs a backlink tool and a short monthly check. A redirect fixes every link that pointed to one dead URL, with no outreach at all. Ahrefs cites a case in which 31 backlinks were reclaimed from 166 emails, an 18.67% conversion rate.
Broken link building needs more hours at every step. You must prospect dead pages, vet their links, write a replacement page, and then run cold outreach. Backlinko and Pitchbox found in 2019 that only 8.5% of 12 million outreach emails got a reply. One follow-up added 65.8% more replies.
BuzzStream found in 2025 that follow-up sequences saw an 85% higher reply rate than one-and-done emails, based on over 65,000 campaigns and over 8 million emails. The first follow-up did most of the work, and replies fell 66% from the first follow-up to the second email.
Both tactics need a paid backlink tool for the full workflow, though Ahrefs offers a free backlink checker for sites you verify. A regular backlink audit keeps the cost down, because it catches lost links early while the linking site still remembers your page.
Which is better for whom
There is no single winner: reclamation wins for older sites, and broken link building wins for newer sites with strong content.
- New sites should start with broken link building. A new site has few links to lose, so there is little to reclaim. A strong guide aimed at dead pages in its niche can earn its first referring domains.
- Established sites should start with reclamation. Years of links mean years of losses, and a redirect can restore many links at once. Run reclamation monthly.
- Small teams should pick reclamation first. It needs less content work and less outreach, so one person can run it in a few hours a month.
- Teams with writers should add broken link building. The tactic only works when the replacement page is good enough to earn the swap, so writing skill is the limit.
Common mistakes
- Chasing every lost link: most lost links are junk, dropped pages, or crawl errors. Filter for the best links first.
- Redirecting to the homepage: a dead guide sent to your homepage does not help the visitor. Redirect to the closest live page.
- Pitching a weak replacement: a thin page that does not match the dead page will not earn the swap. Check the old page first.
- Sending mass outreach: a generic pitch that never names the dead link reads as spam. Name the page and the link.
- Counting unlinked mentions as reclamation: Ahrefs is clear that you cannot reclaim a link you never had.
- Paying for ranking links: do not pay for a link that is meant to pass ranking value.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you do link reclamation and broken link building at the same time?
Yes, and most sites should. Start with reclamation because it is faster and cheaper, then use broken link building for new referring domains. Run reclamation as a monthly check, and run broken link building as a campaign when you publish a strong new page.
How often should you check for lost backlinks?
Check monthly if your site earns links every week, and at least every 3 months if it earns links slowly. Semrush tracks lost and broken domains over the last 90 days, and Ahrefs shows links lost in the past 30 days. Check right after a redesign or migration.
Does broken link building still work in 2026?
Yes, but only when the replacement page is strong and the outreach is specific. Ahrefs calls it the fifth most used tactic, based on Aira's 2022 report from 270 SEOs. Expect low reply rates, since Backlinko and Pitchbox found in 2019 that only 8.5% of outreach emails got a reply.
What is the difference between link reclamation and unlinked brand mentions?
Link reclamation recovers a link you already had and lost. An unlinked brand mention is a page that names your brand but never linked to you, so there is nothing to reclaim. Ahrefs puts it plainly: you cannot reclaim a link you never had.
How long does each tactic take to show results?
Reclamation can show results in days when a redirect restores many links at once, and in weeks when outreach is needed. Broken link building takes longer, since you must find dead pages, write a replacement, and wait for replies. A campaign with no reply in 2 weeks is likely done.
Sources
- Ahrefs: Broken Link Building: The Complete Guide
- Ahrefs: Link Reclamation: How to Find and Reclaim Lost Backlinks
- Ahrefs: At Least 66.5% of Links to Sites in the Last 9 Years Are Dead (2022, updated 2024)
- Semrush: Monitoring Lost and Found Referring Domains
- Backlinko: We Analyzed 12 Million Outreach Emails. Here's What We Learned (2019)
- BuzzStream: Follow-Up Emails in Digital PR: What the Data Tells Us (2025)
- Aira: The State of Link Building Report (2022)
- Pew Research Center: When Online Content Disappears (2024)
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice TeamRelated guides





