Does Disavowing Links Help Rankings?

Disavowing links rarely helps rankings, because Google already ignores most spammy links. It only helps when a manual action for unnatural links is involved.
No, disavowing links does not help rankings for most sites, because Google already ignores most spammy links on its own. Disavowing only helps in narrow cases, such as when a manual action for unnatural links is in place or is likely, and it can hurt when good links get removed by mistake.
Key takeaways
- Google says most sites will never need the disavow tool. Use it only with many spammy links plus a manual action, real or likely (Google, 2026).
- In Ahrefs' 2024 test, disavowing 129 flagged links across 3 posts cut traffic by 7.1% over 20 days (Ahrefs, 2024).
- In Ahrefs' 2021 test, disavowing 3,476 links across 3 posts cut one page's traffic by about 18%, and traffic rose again after the file came off (Ahrefs, 2021).
- John Mueller said Google has no internal idea of "toxic backlinks" and the tool is not normal site maintenance (Search Engine Journal, 2025).
- A disavow file holds up to 100,000 lines and 2 MB, and Google says it can take weeks to act on it (Google Search Console Help, 2026).
What disavowing links means
Disavowing a link means asking Google to ignore it when it judges your site. You list the URLs or domains in a plain text file and upload it in Google Search Console.
The tool dates to 2012, when Google launched it after the Penguin update so sites could clean up paid links. It never deletes a link from the web, and a disavowed link still shows in the Links report in Search Console.
A disavow file is a request, not an order. Google treats it as a hint about which links to ignore, and it only applies to the property you upload it for. A new upload replaces the old list, so keep a copy.
What Google says about disavowing links
Google says most sites should never use the disavow tool, because in most cases it can judge which links to trust without extra guidance.
Google puts it this way: "In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool." That sentence is the core of its advice, as of November 2026.
Google sets a two-part test, and both parts must hold. Disavow only if you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links pointing to your site, and those links have caused a manual action or are likely to cause one.
Google also warns that the tool is an advanced feature that can harm your site in search if used wrongly. Its spam policies define link spam as creating links mainly to move rankings, and list buying links and automated link building as examples.
Google Search Advocate John Mueller said the same at Search Central NYC in 2025: "It's not a part of normal site maintenance." He added that Google has no internal idea of "toxic backlinks", a label from SEO tools.
What studies show about rankings
Controlled tests show disavowing links does not lift rankings, and it can cut traffic. The clearest tests come from Ahrefs, which ran them on its own blog.
In a 2024 test, Ahrefs disavowed 129 URLs flagged as toxic across 3 blog posts on 26 July 2024. Over the next 20 days, their Search Console traffic fell 7.1%, from 1,021 visits to 948 visits.
The page results were mixed: one post fell 12%, from 574 to 505 visits, a second fell 8.25%, from 291 to 267, and a third grew 12.82%, from 156 to 176. Ahrefs judged the net effect as little to no change in rankings or visibility.
The test ran only 20 days because Google started a core update on 15 August 2024. Even so, it fits Google's message: links flagged by tools were already being ignored, so removing them changed nothing.
What happened when Ahrefs disavowed every link
An earlier Ahrefs test from 2021 points the same way. It disavowed 3,476 links across 3 posts for 4 weeks, from 17 August to 14 September 2021. One page lost about 18% of its traffic in the first month, a second lost 13.3%, and traffic rose once the file was removed.
The third page then jumped over 44% in traffic after the file came off. If you are unsure whether your own links are the problem, read our guide on whether backlinks can hurt your SEO before you touch the disavow tool.
When disavowing links can help
Disavowing helps when a manual action for unnatural links is in place, or when one is clearly coming. Google, Ahrefs, and Semrush agree the tool has a real job there.
The second case is a past link scheme you built yourself. If you or an agency you hired bought links, disavow the links you cannot get removed, then file a reconsideration request in Search Console. Without that request, the manual action stays in place.
The third case is a large wave of manipulative links you did not build, such as a flood of paid links aimed at your site. Even then, check the Manual actions report first, because Google says it works hard to keep other sites' actions from hurting yours.
When disavowing links can hurt
Disavowing hurts when the file catches links that were helping you. Tool scores do not match Google's view, so a link flagged as toxic may still pass real value.
Ahrefs' 2024 test showed the risk in real numbers. One post that had been trending up started trending down after the disavow, and its traffic fell 8.25% in 20 days. Some disavowed links had likely helped the page rank.
Paid links are the one area where the risk runs the other way, and how Google detects paid links is worth reading first. Google lists buying or selling links for rankings as link spam, so leaving bought links in place while a manual action is open is worse than disavowing them.
How to disavow links step by step
Start in Search Console, not with a file. Open Security and Manual Actions, then Manual actions, and look for a notice about unnatural links. If it says no issues were found, stop there.
If a manual action exists, audit your links first. A link audit lists every link to your site so you can judge each one on its own, instead of trusting a tool score.
- Try to remove the bad links first by asking the site owners to take them down.
- Build a plain text file, one URL or domain per line, using domain:example.com for whole domains.
- Stay within Google's limits: UTF-8 or 7-bit ASCII, a .txt ending, URLs up to 2,048 characters, at most 100,000 lines and 2 MB.
- Upload the file in the disavow tool for the right property, then file a reconsideration request if you have a manual action.
Expect to wait. Google says it can take a few weeks to fold your list into its index, and disavowed links keep showing in the Links report. Check your rankings and traffic over the next few months.
| Situation | Disavow? | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Manual action for unnatural links | Yes | Remove links, disavow the rest, file a reconsideration request |
| You bought links or ran a link scheme | Yes | Disavow links you cannot remove, stop buying links |
| Tool flags links as toxic, no manual action | No | Leave them alone |
| Random spam links you did not build | No | Ignore them |
Common mistakes
Most disavow mistakes come from treating the tool as routine cleanup. Google's spam systems already ignore most junk links, as our guide to SpamBrain explains.
- Disavowing on a tool score alone: "toxic" is a label from SEO tools, not Google, and Mueller said Google has no internal idea of toxic backlinks. Check each link by hand first.
- Disavowing every link from a low-quality site: a low-traffic site is not proof of a scheme. Google only cares about links built to move rankings.
- Forgetting the reconsideration request: disavowing alone does not lift a manual action. File the request in Search Console after the upload.
- Uploading a partial list: each new upload replaces the old one, so a short file wipes your earlier entries. Always upload the full list.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does disavowing links improve rankings?
No, not for most sites. Google already ignores most spammy links, so disavowing them changes nothing. Ahrefs tested this in 2024 by disavowing 129 flagged links across 3 posts, and traffic fell 7.1% over 20 days instead of rising. Disavowing only helps when it clears a manual action for unnatural links.
How long does it take for a disavow file to work?
Google says it can take a few weeks to fold a disavow list into its index. Recovery from a manual action takes longer: Semrush notes that rankings may need weeks or months to recover after a penalty. Do not judge the file after a few days.
Can disavowing links hurt my site?
Yes. A disavow file tells Google to ignore the links you list, including good ones you list by mistake. In Ahrefs' 2024 test, one page that had been trending up started trending down after its links were disavowed, and its traffic fell 8.25% in 20 days. Google warns that wrong use can harm your site in search.
Should I disavow links flagged as toxic by an SEO tool?
No, not on the score alone. Toxic is a label invented by SEO tools: Google's John Mueller said in 2025 that Google has no internal idea of toxic backlinks. A high score does not mean Google counts the link against you. Disavow only links you can show break Google's rules.
Do I need to disavow links after a negative SEO attack?
Almost never. Google says it works hard to keep actions on other sites from hurting yours, and its systems ignore most spam links. Mueller said in 2025 that sites blaming negative SEO had their own SEO or content problems. Check the Manual actions report, and disavow only if a real action appears.
Sources
- Google Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site (2026)
- Google Search Central: Spam Policies for Google Web Search (2026)
- Search Engine Journal: Google Says Disavow Tool Not Part Of Normal Site Maintenance (2025)
- Ahrefs: I Disavowed "Toxic Backlinks" (2024)
- Ahrefs: Do Links Still Matter for Rankings? (2021)
- Semrush: How to Disavow Backlinks (2025)
If you would rather build links that help instead of cleaning up links that hurt, read our guide on how to build backlinks.
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice TeamRelated guides





