SEO Questions

Can Backlinks Hurt Your SEO?

By BacklinkPrice Team · Nov 18, 2026 · Updated Nov 20, 2026 · 8 min read
Illustrated cover for Can Backlinks Hurt Your SEO?

Yes, backlinks can hurt your SEO when they are paid links or part of a manipulative pattern. Most random spam links are ignored by Google, so check for a manual action before you disavow anything.

Yes, backlinks can hurt your SEO, but only in specific cases: links you bought or built to manipulate rankings, or a clear pattern of such links, can cost you rankings, while most random spam links are ignored by Google. A single odd link from a low quality site is not a penalty. The risk comes from scale and intent.

Key takeaways

  • Yes, backlinks can hurt your SEO when they are paid links or part of a manipulative pattern, and Google says sites that break its spam policies may rank lower or not appear at all (Google, 2026).
  • Google defines link spam as links created mainly to manipulate rankings, including buying links and automated link building (Google, 2026).
  • Since September 2016, Google has mostly devalued spammy links instead of demoting whole sites, so a few junk links usually cause no harm (Ahrefs, 2024).
  • In Ahrefs' 2024 test, disavowing 129 tool-flagged links across 3 posts cut combined traffic by 7.1% in 20 days (Ahrefs, 2024).
  • Disavow links only when you have many spammy links and they have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action (Ahrefs, 2024, quoting Google).

A harmful backlink is a link that Google treats as link spam, not just a link from a site you dislike.

Link spam is a link created mainly to manipulate search rankings, and the intent behind the link matters more than the look of the linking site.

A link becomes a problem when it was bought, exchanged, or placed at scale to pass ranking credit.

Ahrefs draws a clear line between three labels in its 2024 guide to toxic backlinks:

  • Spammy links are low quality links that every site attracts.
  • Manipulative links are links built or bought solely to improve Google rankings.
  • Toxic links are links that certain SEO tools say could hurt your rankings, based on markers those tools chose.

That last label is a tool label, not a Google label, because Google does not use the word toxic for links.

Semrush scores each link on a Toxicity Score from 0 to 100, with 0 to 44 counted as non-toxic, 45 to 59 as potentially toxic, and 60 to 100 as toxic (Semrush, 2026).

Google says link spam is the practice of creating links to or from a site mainly to manipulate search rankings.

Its spam policies page, read in November 2026, lists buying or selling links for ranking purposes as the first example.

That covers exchanging money for links or posts that contain links, exchanging goods or services for links, and sending a product in exchange for a post with a link.

The same page lists excessive link exchanges, automated programs used to create links, links required by a contract, and text ads that do not block ranking credit.

Google states that sites that break these policies may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all.

Buying links is against Google's guidelines when the links pass ranking credit, so the safe form of a paid link is one qualified with rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored".

How Penguin changed the risk in 2016

Penguin is the Google system that deals with manipulative links, and its change in September 2016 lowered the risk from single bad links.

Ahrefs notes in its 2024 guide that if you asked before September 2016 whether spammy links hurt rankings, the answer would likely have been yes, and now it is probably not.

The change was that Penguin became more granular and started to devalue bad links instead of demoting sites.

Google put it this way in 2016: "Penguin now devalues spam by adjusting ranking based on spam signals, rather than affecting ranking of the whole site."

That sentence is 19 words, and it is the core of the modern answer.

Devalue means the link stops counting, while demote means the site drops. A devalued link gives you nothing, but it does not push you down by itself.

What studies and tests show

The clearest test of tool-flagged bad links comes from Ahrefs in 2024.

On July 26, 2024, Ahrefs head of content Joshua Hardwick exported all toxic and potentially toxic backlinks to 3 Ahrefs blog posts from a well-known SEO tool.

There were 129 URLs in total, and he disavowed them all in Google Search Console.

He compared 20 days before the disavow with 20 days after, and cut the test short because Google began a core update on August 15, 2024.

Combined traffic in Google Search Console fell by 7.1%, from 1,021 visits to 948 visits.

The results by page:

  • Page 1 fell by 12%, from 574 visits to 505 visits.
  • Page 2 fell by 8.25%, from 291 visits to 267 visits.
  • Page 3 grew by 12.82%, from 156 visits to 176 visits.

Patrick Stox of Ahrefs said to judge the test by Ahrefs data, not Search Console data.

Hardwick reached the same view: blindly disavowing tool-flagged links is unlikely to have much, if any, positive impact.

Backlinks can still hurt your SEO in three clear cases, and each one involves a pattern or a manual action.

First, a manual action for unnatural links is the direct case. A human reviewer at Google has judged that your links break the spam policies, and the site can be demoted until the links are removed or disavowed and the action is lifted.

Second, a large volume of paid or manipulative links can hurt even without a manual action. Ahrefs states in its 2024 guide that if you are buying or building the types of links Google classes as link spam, then yes, they can absolutely hurt your rankings. Google looks for patterns, not single links.

Third, the December 2022 link spam update made detection stronger.

Google said on December 14, 2022 that its AI-based system SpamBrain can now detect both sites buying links and sites used to pass outgoing links, and that ranking may change as spammy links are neutralized and credit from unnatural links is lost.

That update took about 2 weeks to roll out and applied to all languages.

Exceptions and nuance

Most of the exceptions point in the same direction: Google ignores far more bad links than it punishes.

A single low quality link, a link from an irrelevant site, or a link with odd anchor text will not hurt a normal site.

Ahrefs notes that a single low quality link probably will not pose a threat, and only a large number of spammy links can draw attention from Google's webspam team or lower rankings.

Negative SEO is the most cited exception, and the evidence for it is weak.

Negative SEO is when a rival points spammy links at your site to try to get you penalized.

Gary Illyes of Google said he had looked at hundreds of supposed cases, but none had actually been the real reason a website was hurt.

What to do in practice

Check the Manual Actions report first, because a manual action for unnatural links is the one case where cleanup is clearly required.

If there is no manual action, look at your anchors and your referring domains for exact match commercial phrases and links from the same network.

Try to remove the worst links first.

Use the disavow tool only when Google's own test is met: you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links, and they have caused a manual action or are likely to cause one.

John Mueller said in 2025 that the disavow tool is not part of normal site maintenance, and he would only use it if you have a manual spam action (Search Engine Journal, 2025).

Do not disavow links just because a tool scored them as toxic.

Dr. Marie Haynes put it plainly: "While there is no harm in disavowing low quality spammy links, it likely does not help improve rankings."

SituationLikely harmWhat to do
A few random spam links you did not buildLowIgnore them
Paid links or a link scheme you took part inHighRemove them, then disavow the rest
Manual action for unnatural linksHighRemove links, disavow the rest, request a review
Sudden flood of spam links you did not buildMediumDocument the spike, check for a manual action
Tool-flagged toxic links, no manual actionLowDo not disavow on the score alone

Common mistakes

  • Disavowing on a tool score alone: a toxicity score is a vendor estimate, not a Google judgment, and disavowing good links by mistake can cut traffic.
  • Disavowing every low quality link: Google already ignores most random spam, so a long disavow file adds work and risk with little gain.
  • Buying links and hoping nofollow is not needed: a paid link that passes ranking credit breaks Google's spam policies.
  • Ignoring a manual action: a manual action will not clear itself, and you need to remove or disavow the links and then request a review.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, one bad backlink will not hurt your SEO in almost every case. Google ignores most single spammy links, and Ahrefs notes that a single low quality link probably will not pose a threat. Harm comes from a pattern of many manipulative links, or a manual action.

Tool-flagged toxic backlinks usually do not hurt rankings on their own, because toxic is a label from SEO tools, not a term Google uses. Google ignores most spammy links and acts on patterns of manipulation instead. In Ahrefs' 2024 test, disavowing 129 tool-flagged links had little to no impact overall.

Disavow backlinks only if you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links and they have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action. That is Google's own test, quoted by Ahrefs in 2024. Most sites never need the tool.

A competitor can point spammy links at your site, but Google says this rarely works. Gary Illyes of Google said he had looked at hundreds of supposed negative SEO cases and none had actually been the real reason a website was hurt.

Sources

BacklinkPrice Team
Written by
BacklinkPrice Team
Link building and backlink pricing research

The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.

More from BacklinkPrice Team

Related guides