What Is Blog Commenting for SEO? How It Works and Why It Matters for SEO

Blog commenting for SEO is leaving a useful comment on a blog post with a link back to your site. Most comment links are nofollow, so expect traffic and trust, not direct ranking credit.
Blog commenting for SEO is the practice of leaving a comment on a blog post with a link back to your own site, in the hope that the link helps your rankings. Most comment links carry nofollow or ugc, so they pass little or no direct ranking credit, yet a useful comment can still send readers and earn later links.
Key takeaways
- Google introduced rel="nofollow" in 2005 to fight comment spam, and WordPress adds nofollow to comment links by default (Google Search Central Blog, 2019; Ahrefs).
- A Semrush study of 1,000 domains in 2025 found nofollow links had a Pearson correlation of 0.340 with AI mentions, next to 0.334 for follow links (Semrush, 2025).
- Backlinko's analysis of 11.8 million Google results found the top result has 3.8 times more backlinks than results in positions 2 to 10 (Backlinko, 2025).
- Google lists forum comments with optimized links and automated link creation as examples of link spam, and sites that break the rules may rank lower or not appear at all (Google Search Central).
- Check a comment link by viewing the page source and looking for rel="nofollow" or rel="ugc", then track referral visits in your analytics tool.
What blog commenting for SEO means
Blog commenting for SEO means posting a comment on another site's blog, usually with your name linked to your site, to gain a link, traffic, or a relationship with the author.
A comment can carry two kinds of link. The name field often links your display name to your home page, while a link inside the comment text points to a specific page you mention.
That is different from an editorial link, which a site owner places in an article because the page deserves a mention. A comment link is placed by you, on a page you do not control, so search engines treat it with more doubt.
Blog commenting also differs from guest posting, where you write a full article for another site. A comment is short, sits below the article, and rarely carries the same weight as a link inside the article text.
How blog commenting works
A comment link works in four steps: you find a post, you submit a comment with a link, the site owner approves it, and search engines then decide how to treat the link.
Most blogs hold comments for review before they appear. The owner can approve, edit, delete, or mark a comment as spam, and many blogs close comments after a set time, so old posts stop accepting new links.
When the comment goes live, the link usually carries rel="nofollow" or rel="ugc". Google recommends marking links in comments and forum posts with ugc, and says links marked with these values will generally not be followed.
Google introduced nofollow in 2005 to fight comment spam, after spammers filled comment boxes with links to raise their own sites. In September 2019 it added sponsored and ugc, and said all three values are hints, not orders, for ranking (Google Search Central Blog, 2019).
Since 1 March 2020, nofollow has also been a hint for crawling and indexing, so Google may still find the linked page through a sitemap or another link. A comment link is therefore a weak signal, not a blocked one.
Why blog commenting matters for rankings
Blog commenting matters for rankings only a little, because most comment links pass no direct ranking credit. Its value comes from traffic, visibility, and the followed links it can lead to later. Bad links can also hurt, so quality matters more than count.
Google does not transfer PageRank or anchor text across nofollow links, according to Ahrefs, and Google says marked links will generally not be followed. A single comment link will not lift a page on its own.
Backlinko's analysis of 11.8 million Google results found the top result has 3.8 times more backlinks than results in positions 2 to 10, and about 95% of all pages have zero backlinks (Backlinko, 2025). A dofollow link passes credit in the normal way, while a nofollow link does not.
Ahrefs studied 44,589 search results pages and found the link between dofollow backlinks and rankings was slightly weaker than the link for total backlinks. That hints that Google may value some nofollow links from strong pages, though Ahrefs warns the result needs care (Ahrefs).
Why blog commenting matters for AI search
Blog commenting matters for AI search because AI systems read mentions and links as signs of trust, and they do not discount nofollow links the way classic ranking does. Strong links still help a site get cited, so comments work best beside other link building.
Semrush studied 1,000 domains in 2025 across ChatGPT, ChatGPT with Search, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, and Perplexity. Nofollow links had a Pearson correlation of 0.340 with AI mentions, next to 0.334 for follow links, so the two were almost the same (Semrush, 2025).
The same study found that authority and quality predicted AI visibility far more than raw link volume. A handful of extra low-value links rarely moved anything, while links from respected, relevant sites could (Semrush, 2025).
A comment on a respected blog can therefore help AI visibility even when its link is nofollow, because the mention puts your name and site in front of readers who may cite you later. Treat comments as a way to be seen, not as a way to buy ranking credit.
Real examples of good and bad blog comments
A good blog comment adds to the post, while a bad one only promotes a link. The difference is clear in the words, not in the link itself.
Good example: on a post about fixing broken links, a reader writes two sentences about a redirect loop they fixed, then links to their short guide on the same fix. The comment helps readers and fits the topic.
Bad example: on the same post, a reader writes 'Great post!' and links the words 'best cheap loans' to a loan site. The comment adds nothing, the anchor is optimized, and the link has nothing to do with the topic.
A second good example is a short correction. A reader points out that a tool price in the post changed, gives the new price, and links to the vendor's pricing page as proof. The author may then fix the post and remember the reader.
A second bad example is a copy-paste comment. The same text appears under many posts on many blogs, with only the link changed. Site owners spot the pattern fast, and the comments often end in spam folders.
How to check and measure blog comment links
You can check a comment link in under a minute, and measure its effect over weeks. Start with the link itself, then watch the traffic it sends.
- Open the live post, find your comment, right-click the link, and choose Inspect. Look at the HTML for rel="nofollow" or rel="ugc" to see how the link is marked.
- Check the page in a backlink tool, such as Ahrefs Site Explorer, and filter for your domain. Note the date the tool first saw the link, and whether it is still live a week later.
- Look at referral visits in your analytics tool for the blog's domain. A comment that sends real readers is worth more than one that only adds a line to a backlink report.
Judge the work after 4 weeks, not after 4 days. A comment needs time to be crawled, read, and shared, so a one-day check tells you almost nothing.
Good vs bad blog commenting and the risks
Good blog commenting is slow, on topic, and useful to readers. Bad blog commenting is fast, off topic, and built only to place links.
| Comment | Link | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Adds a fact | nofollow or ugc | Readers click |
| Pushes a loan link | nofollow or ugc | Spam folder |
Google lists forum comments with optimized links in the post or signature as an example of link spam. It also lists using automated programs or services to create links to your site (Google Search Central).
Buying or selling links for ranking purposes is also link spam under Google's rules. A paid comment link that passes ranking credit breaks those rules, so a link you pay for must carry nofollow or sponsored (Google Search Central).
Sites that break the rules may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all, according to Google. That risk falls on the site that hosts the links and on the site the links point to, so both sides should care. Our guide to Google's link spam policies explains the full list.
Common mistakes
These five mistakes turn a useful habit into a waste of time. Avoid them, and a comment is far more likely to stay live.
- Leaving the same comment on many blogs: readers and site owners spot the pattern, the comments look automated, and most of them are deleted or marked as spam.
- Using optimized anchor text in a comment: a keyword-rich link in a comment or signature is a link spam example in Google's rules, so use your name or a plain link instead.
- Commenting only to get a link: a comment with no value for readers sends no traffic and earns no trust, so write the comment as if the link were not there.
- Chasing dofollow comment blogs: removing nofollow from comment links is a plugin setting, not a sign of quality, and a dofollow link on a spam-filled blog is worth little.
- Believing comment links alone will rank a page: most comment links pass no direct credit, so use comments beside stronger links, such as editorial mentions and guest posts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does blog commenting help SEO?
Yes, but only a little and mostly through indirect effects. Most comment links are nofollow or ugc, so they pass no direct ranking credit. A useful comment can still send readers, build a relationship with a blogger, and lead to a followed link later, which is where the real value sits.
Are blog comment links dofollow or nofollow?
Most are nofollow or ugc. WordPress adds nofollow to comment links by default, and Google recommends ugc for links in comments and forum posts. A few blogs remove the mark for trusted commenters, but you should expect nofollow and judge a comment by its readers, not its link mark.
Can blog commenting get your site penalized?
Yes, if you do it at scale with spammy methods. Google lists automated link creation and forum comments with optimized links as link spam, and sites that break its rules may rank lower or not appear at all. A few honest comments on relevant blogs carry no such risk.
How many blog comments should you leave each week?
There is no fixed number, and Google sets none. A few thoughtful comments on blogs your readers actually visit beat dozens of short, generic ones. Pick 3 to 5 posts a week where you can add a fact, a fix, or a useful example, then stop.
Does blog commenting help with AI search?
It can help a little. A Semrush study of 1,000 domains in 2025 found nofollow links had almost the same correlation with AI mentions as follow links, at 0.340 against 0.334. A comment on a respected blog can put your site in front of people who later cite you in AI answers.
Sources
If you want a wider plan, read our guide on how to build backlinks.
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice TeamRelated guides





