Can Competitors Hurt You with Bad Backlinks?

No, a competitor usually cannot hurt you with bad backlinks. Google ignores most spammy links, and its staff found no real case where a negative SEO attack worked.
No, a competitor usually cannot hurt you with bad backlinks, because Google ignores most spammy links on its own. Negative SEO is a rival pointing spammy links at your site to trigger a penalty, but Google says its systems spot that trick and its staff found no real case where it worked.
Key takeaways
- Google defines link spam as links made mainly to move rankings (Google Search Central, 2026).
- SpamBrain, Google's AI spam system, neutralizes unnatural links so they pass no ranking value (Google, 2022).
- Google's Gary Illyes said he reviewed hundreds of supposed negative SEO cases and none was the real reason a site was hurt (Ahrefs, 2026).
- In Ahrefs' 2024 test, disavowing 129 flagged links cut traffic 7.1% over 20 days, so blind disavows can backfire (Ahrefs, 2024).
- Disavow only when you have many spammy links plus a manual action, or one is likely (Google Search Console Help, 2026).
What negative SEO means
Negative SEO is an attack in which a rival builds spammy links to your site to make Google distrust it. The idea is simple: if bad links can trigger a penalty, a rival can buy them for you.
Common forms include floods of low-quality directory links, forum comment spam, links from hacked pages, and waves of exact-match anchor text. Each form tries to make your link profile look bought, not earned. Our guide to what negative SEO is explains the tactic in full.
The fear is older than the defense. Before September 2016, Penguin could demote whole pages over spammy links, but it then became granular and started to devalue bad links instead (Ahrefs, 2026). That shift changed the math for attackers.
What Google says about competitor backlinks
Google says a rival's links should not decide your rankings, because its systems judge links by intent and pattern, not by who built them. Its spam policies define link spam as creating links to or from a site mainly to manipulate search rankings (Google Search Central, 2026).
The examples include buying or selling links for ranking purposes, excessive link exchanges, and automated link building programs. Google's link spam policies list each pattern it treats as a violation, as of November 2026.
Google also says it detects policy breaks through automated systems and, where needed, human review that can result in a manual action (Google Search Central, 2026). A site that breaks the rules may rank lower or not appear in results at all.
That warning is aimed at sites that build manipulative links themselves, not at sites that receive them.
How SpamBrain and Penguin treat bad links
SpamBrain is Google's AI-based spam prevention system, and it neutralizes unnatural links instead of punishing the site that received them. Google launched the December 2022 link spam update on December 14, 2022, to put SpamBrain to work on unnatural links (Google, 2022).
Google said the update would take about 2 weeks to roll out across all languages, and rankings may change as spammy links are neutralized and the credit they passed is lost (Google, 2022).
SpamBrain can now detect both sites that buy links and sites used to pass outgoing links, according to the same 2022 announcement. Google's answer to a flood of bought links is to cancel their value.
Penguin added the same logic earlier. It now devalues spam by adjusting rankings based on spam signals, rather than hitting the whole site (Ahrefs, 2026).
What studies and tests show
The data agrees with Google: random spammy links rarely move rankings, and reacting to them can do more harm than the links did. Google's John Mueller has said site owners should ignore single spammy links, because Google's systems have seen such links many times and are good at ignoring them (Ahrefs, 2026).
The strongest direct evidence comes from Gary Illyes of Google. He said he had looked at hundreds of supposed negative SEO cases and none had actually been the real reason a website was hurt (Ahrefs, 2026).
Traffic drops blamed on rivals usually had another cause, such as an algorithm update or a site problem. Check updates, technical faults, and content changes first.
Ahrefs also ran a test in 2024 that shows why a hasty cleanup is risky, as our guide on whether to disavow spammy links explains. It disavowed 129 flagged links across 3 posts, and combined traffic fell 7.1% over 20 days, from 1,021 visits to 948 (Ahrefs, 2024).
When bad links can still hurt
Bad links can still hurt when they form a strong pattern that looks like your own link scheme. Google's John Mueller has said a very strong pattern of spammy links can make its algorithms lose trust in a site and rank it more cautiously (Ahrefs, 2026).
A manual action is the sharper risk. A human reviewer who finds a pattern of unnatural links pointing at your site can apply an action called "Unnatural links to your site," and some or all of the site may then vanish from search results.
A sudden flood of paid-looking links still deserves a check, even if most floods turn out harmless. Our guide to whether backlinks can hurt your SEO covers when a manual action is most likely.
How to tell if a link attack is hurting you
Start with the Manual Actions report in Google Search Console. If it shows no action, check updates, technical faults, and content changes before you blame the links.
Next, look at the shape of the new links, not just the count. Check for shared anchor text, the same kind of low-quality pages, or links aimed at one money page.
Semrush rates a profile as high toxicity when more than 10% of audited links are toxic, medium at 3% to 9%, and low below 3% (Semrush, 2026). Treat that score as a prompt to look closer, not as a verdict from Google.
A full backlink audit walks through these checks in order. Group the links by domain and judge each group before you act.
| Signal | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Few random spam links | Normal noise every site gets | Ignore them |
| Flood with one anchor | Possible attack or old scheme | Check Manual Actions |
| Manual action shown | Google found a pattern | Remove, then disavow |
What to do in practice
Do nothing about random spammy links. Act only when the evidence points to a real pattern or a manual action, and first note the date of any traffic drop against known update dates and changes you made.
If there is no action and no clear pattern, leave the links alone.
If a manual action exists, ask site owners to remove the bad links first, then disavow what is left. Google's help page sets a two-part test: disavow only if you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links, and those links have caused a manual action or are likely to cause one (Google Search Console Help, 2026).
Filing a disavow does not itself mark your site as suspicious. Google's John Mueller said the tool is purely technical, telling Google to ignore the listed links, and it is not an admission of guilt (Search Engine Journal, 2021).
Google also says: "In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool." Learn how the file works in our guide to the disavow tool.
Why a hasty disavow can backfire
Check every link by hand before you disavow anything, because a tool can flag links that were helping you. In Ahrefs' 2024 test, disavowing 129 flagged links across 3 posts cut combined traffic by 7.1% over 20 days (Ahrefs, 2024).
One post fell 12%, from 574 visits to 505, and a second fell 8.25%, from 291 to 267 visits. A third post rose 12.82%, from 156 to 176 visits, so the effect was mixed across the three pages.
The test was cut short by a core update on August 15, 2024, so 20 days is a short window. The lesson stands: disavow on evidence, not on a score. See how to remove toxic backlinks before you file anything.
Common mistakes
- Disavowing every link a tool flags as toxic. A "toxic" label comes from the tool, not from Google, and Ahrefs' 2024 test showed disavowing flagged links can cut traffic.
- Blaming a rival before checking your own site. Gary Illyes of Google said none of the hundreds of supposed cases he reviewed was the real cause.
- Treating a toxicity score as a Google verdict. Semrush marks a link toxic at a score of 60 to 100, potentially toxic at 45 to 59, and non-toxic at 0 to 44 (Search Engine Land, 2026), but Google does not use that score.
- Ignoring a real manual action. If Search Console shows "Unnatural links to your site," remove links, disavow the rest, and request a review. See our guide to manual actions for unnatural links.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a competitor destroy my rankings with spammy backlinks?
Almost never. Google's systems are built to ignore most spammy links, and Gary Illyes of Google said none of the hundreds of supposed negative SEO cases he reviewed was the real reason a site was hurt. Check the Manual Actions report before you assume an attack.
How do I know if I am under a negative SEO attack?
Look for a sudden flood of new referring domains with the same anchor text, links from low-quality or hacked pages, and a traffic drop on the same dates. Check the Manual Actions report first: no action means the flood is probably harmless noise.
Should I disavow links after a competitor attacks me?
Not by default. Disavow only if you have a considerable number of spammy links and they have caused a manual action or are likely to cause one. Google says most sites will never need the tool. Disavowing good links by mistake can cut your traffic, as Ahrefs' 2024 test showed.
What is the difference between spammy links and toxic links?
Spammy links are low-quality links every site attracts, while "toxic" is a tool label for links thought to hurt rankings. Google has no internal idea of toxic backlinks. Manipulative links are the ones that matter: links built or bought mainly to move rankings.
Can Google tell who built the bad links?
Google does not need to know who built them. Its systems judge the links by pattern and intent, then neutralize the ones made to manipulate rankings. That is why a rival's links usually pass no value, and a pattern that looks like your own scheme is the real risk.
Sources
The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.
More from BacklinkPrice TeamRelated guides





