SEO Questions

Why Did My Traffic Drop After Getting Backlinks?

By BacklinkPrice Team · Nov 19, 2026 · Updated Nov 20, 2026 · 8 min read
Illustrated cover for Why Did My Traffic Drop After Getting Backlinks?

Yes, traffic can fall after new backlinks, but the new links are often not the cause. Check the Manual Actions report and the dates before you blame the links.

Yes, traffic can fall after you gain backlinks, but the new links are often not the cause. A drop that starts right after new links appear may come from SpamBrain removing their credit, a manual action, a core update, or a change on your own site.

Key takeaways

  • Google defines link spam as links built mainly to move rankings, and paid links need rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" (Google, 2026).
  • SpamBrain neutralizes unnatural links, so rankings can fall when the credit they passed is lost (Google, 2022).
  • A manual action for unnatural links shows in Search Console. Violating sites may rank lower or vanish (Google, 2026).
  • In Ahrefs' 2024 test, disavowing 129 flagged links cut traffic to 3 posts by 7.1% in 20 days (Ahrefs, 2024).
  • Check the Manual Actions report and the dates before you blame new links (Google, 2026).

Traffic can fall after new backlinks appear because the links may pass no value, or because another change landed at the same time.

A new link helps only if Google counts it. If SpamBrain judges it unnatural, it removes the credit it passed, so the page keeps the link but gains nothing. The rankings it seemed to support can then slip back.

Timing can mislead you. A drop that starts the day new links go live may share a date with a core update or a site change. The date match alone proves nothing, as our guide explains.

Lost links can also explain a sudden fall. Ahrefs notes that losing many of your best backlinks overnight can make rankings drop fast.

Google says links built mainly to move rankings are link spam, and buying links for that purpose breaks its rules.

Google defines link spam as creating links to or from a site mainly to manipulate search rankings. Its examples include buying or selling links, excessive link exchanges, automated link building, and low-quality directory links. The full list sits in Google's spam policies.

  • Buying or selling links for ranking purposes, including money, goods, or services for a link.
  • Excessive link exchanges, partner pages built only for cross-linking, and automated link building.
  • Footer or template links across many sites, and optimized links in forum comments.

Paid links are not always a violation. Google says buying and selling links is normal for ads, and it is fine with rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored". Without that tag, a paid link breaks the policy.

SpamBrain now removes the ranking credit from unnatural links, so bad links usually waste money instead of bringing a penalty.

Google launched the December 2022 link spam update on December 14, 2022, using SpamBrain, its AI-based spam-prevention system. SpamBrain can now detect both sites buying links and sites used for passing outgoing links. Google said the rollout would take about two weeks, in all languages.

Google said rankings may change as spammy links are neutralized and their credit is lost. In its own words, the update works to "neutralize the impact of unnatural links" on search results.

That matters for a fresh batch of links. If the new links were bought to move rankings, SpamBrain can cancel their value soon after Google finds them.

A manual action is a human reviewer's decision, and it is the only link problem Google tells you about directly.

Google detects breaches through automated systems and, when needed, human review that can lead to a manual action. The link action is called "Unnatural links to your site": a reviewer found a pattern of paid or manipulative links pointing at your site.

If a manual action is in place, some or all of the site may not show in Google search results. It is the easiest link cause to confirm, because Search Console lists it with the pages it affects.

Try to remove the bad links first, then disavow the rest. Read our guide to a Google manual action for unnatural links for the full check.

What studies and tests show

Tests show links still pass value, and removing flagged links can cut traffic.

In Ahrefs' disavow experiment, its team disavowed 129 URLs flagged as toxic or possibly toxic across 3 blog posts on July 26, 2024, then compared the 20 days before and after. Search Console traffic fell by 7.1%.

One post fell 12%, from 574 visits to 505, a second fell 8.25%, from 291 to 267, and a third rose 12.82%, from 156 to 176.

Patrick Stox read the data as little to no impact on rankings overall. The test was cut short by a core update that began on August 15, 2024, so the window stayed at 20 days.

Ahrefs also tested the negative SEO fear. Google's stance as of 2021 is that it does not work: Gary Illyes said he had looked at hundreds of supposed cases without finding one that was the real reason a site was hurt.

Its free backlink checker still gets about 133,000 organic visits a month, despite over 1 million spammy pages linking to it.

Semrush's 2024 study ranked referring domain diversity 12th among ranking factors: 100 backlinks from 100 domains will typically beat 100 from 10 domains.

New backlinks hurt when they form a clear pattern of manipulation, not when a few stray spam links point at your site.

The risky patterns are the ones Google lists: paid links at scale, large link exchanges, automated link building, and links in footers, templates, or directories.

Tool scores do not decide this. Moz's Spam Score runs from 1 to 100, with 1 to 30 rated low, 31 to 60 medium, and 61 to 100 high, based on 27 signals and updated every quarter.

Google does not use the score to rank pages, and it does not appear in Search Console. See Diib's Spam Score guide for how Moz builds the number, and our Spam Score guide for the bands.

Google also says it works hard so that third-party actions do not hurt a website, and random spam links you did not build are usually ignored. See Google's disavow help page.

What to do in practice

Start in Search Console, match the dates, and change nothing until you know the cause.

  1. Open the Manual Actions report in Search Console. If it shows "Unnatural links to your site", work on removal first.
  1. Note the date the drop began and the date the new links appeared. If the dates differ by weeks, the links are probably not the trigger.
  1. Export your links from the Links report and list the new referring domains and anchor text. A backlink audit gives you that list.
  1. Ask linking sites to remove bad links. For the rest, read what Google says about disavowing links before you file anything.
CauseFirst check
Neutralized linksCompare the dates
Manual actionOpen Manual Actions report
Lost good linksCheck lost backlinks

Disavow only when Google's tests say so, because a broad disavow can cut traffic instead of saving it.

Disavow only if Google's two tests both hold: a considerable number of spammy links, and a manual action they caused or are likely to cause. Google warns the tool can harm performance if used wrongly.

If you must disavow, keep the file exact. Google caps it at 100,000 lines and 2 MB, with URLs up to 2,048 characters.

Do not buy more links to fix the drop. Buying links to move rankings is link spam, so a second batch can repeat the problem. Learn how to remove toxic backlinks instead.

Google's John Mueller said at Search Central NYC in 2025, as reported by Search Engine Journal: "It's not a part of normal site maintenance." Use the tool for a manual action, not as a routine.

Common mistakes

  • Blaming new links first: open the Manual Actions report first, because a confirmed action is the only link cause Google reports.
  • Disavowing every link a tool flags: in Ahrefs' 2024 test, that move cut traffic to 3 posts by 7.1% in 20 days.
  • Treating a high Spam Score as a Google penalty: Moz's score is a third-party estimate that Google does not use.
  • Filing a disavow as routine cleanup: Google says most sites will never need the tool.
  • Buying a second batch of links to fix the drop: paid links that pass ranking credit are link spam.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, not usually. Google says it works hard so that third-party actions do not hurt your site, and it ignores most stray spam links. A drop needs a pattern, such as paid links at scale, or a manual action. Check the Manual Actions report first.

There is no fixed window. SpamBrain acts when Google recrawls the linking pages, so a fall can show days or weeks later. Google says a disavow can take a few weeks to fold into its index. Match the drop date to the link date before you draw a line between them.

Only if Google's two tests both hold: many spammy, artificial, or low-quality links, and a manual action those links caused or are likely to cause. If neither holds, leave the links alone and look for another cause before you file a disavow.

Removing them stops the risk, but it does not add back rankings. The credit the bad links passed is gone once SpamBrain neutralizes them, so recovery means earning links that pass Google's test and fixing the issues behind the drop.

Almost never through links alone. Google's stance as of 2021 is that negative SEO does not work, because its systems ignore spam links rather than punish the site they point at. Check for a manual action or a change on your own site first.

Sources

Before you pay for more links, check current guest post prices so the next batch does not repeat the mistake.

BacklinkPrice Team
Written by
BacklinkPrice Team
Link building and backlink pricing research

The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.

More from BacklinkPrice Team

Related guides